Ghabouli Mohammad J, Sabouri Amir Hasan, Shoeibi Naser, Bajestan Sepideh Naghibzadeh, Baradaran H
Department of Infectious Diseases, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Eur J Epidemiol. 2004;19(9):871-5. doi: 10.1023/b:ejep.0000040532.99890.9f.
Intradermal (ID) vaccination has been proposed as a cost-saving alternative for administration of Hepatitis B (HB) vaccine to implement of mass vaccination of high-risk groups, particularly in developing countries. Therefore, the effectiveness of ID vaccination needs to be evaluated and verified in different ethnic backgrounds. The present study is a randomized trail using a recombinant vaccine (Heberbiovac) to compare immunogenecity and safety of an intradermal low-dose (4 microg) with standard dose (20 microg) of intramuscular (IM) vaccination in healthy Iranian population. Participants were 143 healthy Iranian medical and nursing students randomly allocated to ID or IM vaccination group. The vaccine was inoculated at 0, 1 and 6 months intervals. Serum samples were collected 1 month after the last vaccination and the anti-HBs response was determined using ELISA. The overall seroprotection rate (anti-HBs level > or = 10 IU/L) was 97.3% for ID vaccination group, which was not different from that of IM vaccination group (98.55%) (p = 0.99). Similarly, geometric mean titers (GMT) of anti-HBs were not significantly different between ID (1164.1 IU/L) and IM (1071.8 IU/L) vaccination groups (p = 0.4). There was no significant difference in seroprotection rate and GMT of anti-HBs between sexes. Although induration and hyperpigmentation at the site of injection were more frequently observed in ID vaccination group, no other clinically adverse effects were observed in both vaccination groups. We conclude that the ID route, which would require one-fifth of the standard dose, would be suitable for use in certain groups such as high-risk adults when the cost of vaccine is the inhibiting factor for mass vaccination.
皮内(ID)接种疫苗已被提议作为一种节省成本的替代方法,用于对高危人群进行乙型肝炎(HB)疫苗大规模接种,特别是在发展中国家。因此,需要在不同种族背景下评估和验证皮内接种疫苗的有效性。本研究是一项随机试验,使用重组疫苗(Heberbiovac)比较健康伊朗人群中皮内低剂量(4微克)与标准剂量(20微克)肌肉注射(IM)接种疫苗的免疫原性和安全性。参与者为143名健康的伊朗医学和护理专业学生,随机分配到皮内或肌肉注射接种组。疫苗在0、1和6个月间隔接种。在最后一次接种后1个月采集血清样本,并使用酶联免疫吸附测定法(ELISA)测定抗-HBs反应。皮内接种组的总体血清保护率(抗-HBs水平≥10 IU/L)为97.3%,与肌肉注射接种组(98.55%)无差异(p = 0.99)。同样,皮内(1164.1 IU/L)和肌肉注射(1071.8 IU/L)接种组之间抗-HBs的几何平均滴度(GMT)无显著差异(p = 0.4)。两性之间抗-HBs的血清保护率和GMT无显著差异。虽然在皮内接种组更频繁地观察到注射部位的硬结和色素沉着,但在两个接种组中均未观察到其他临床不良反应。我们得出结论,当疫苗成本是大规模接种的抑制因素时,皮内接种途径(所需标准剂量的五分之一)适用于某些人群,如高危成年人。