Wu Yvonne W, Day Steven M, Strauss David J, Shavelle Robert M
Department of Neurology, Box 0136, University of California-San Francisco, 500 Parnassus Ave, Room 411, San Francisco, CA 94143-0136, USA.
Pediatrics. 2004 Nov;114(5):1264-71. doi: 10.1542/peds.2004-0114.
To determine independent predictors of ambulation among children with cerebral palsy and to develop a simple tool that estimates the probability that a child will walk.
In a retrospective study of all children with cerebral palsy who were not yet walking at 2 to 3(1/2) years of age, while receiving services from the California Department of Developmental Services during the years 1987-1999, we analyzed medical and functional data obtained annually by Department of Developmental Services physicians and social workers. Using logistic regression analyses, we determined independent predictors of a child's ability to walk well alone at least 20 feet, without assistive devices, by age 6. We then estimated the probabilities of walking at various levels of ability over time, using multistate survival analysis.
Of 5366 study subjects, 2295 (43%) were evaluated at age 6; 12.8% could walk independently and 18.4% walked with support. Independent predictors of successful ambulation included early motor milestones such as sitting (odds ratio: 12.5; 95% confidence interval: 5.8-27.2) and pulling to a stand (odds ratio: 28.5; 95% confidence interval: 13.4-60.4) when compared with lack of rolling at age 2, cerebral palsy type other than spastic quadriparesis (odds ratio: 2.2; 95% confidence interval: 1.5-3.1), and preserved visual function (odds ratio: 2.4; 95% confidence interval: 1.1-5.4). Our ambulation charts depict the probability of remaining nonambulatory, transitioning to 1 of 3 possible ambulatory states, or expiring at all subsequent ages through age 14.
The ambulation charts provide a simple straightforward way to estimate the probability that a child with cerebral palsy who is nonambulatory at 2 to 3 12 years of age will eventually walk with or without support.
确定脑瘫患儿步行能力的独立预测因素,并开发一种简单工具来估计儿童行走的概率。
在一项对1987年至1999年期间接受加利福尼亚发展服务部服务、2至3.5岁尚未开始行走的所有脑瘫患儿的回顾性研究中,我们分析了发展服务部医生和社会工作者每年获取的医学和功能数据。通过逻辑回归分析,我们确定了儿童在6岁时无需辅助设备独自良好行走至少20英尺能力的独立预测因素。然后,我们使用多状态生存分析估计了不同能力水平随时间推移行走的概率。
在5366名研究对象中,2295名(43%)在6岁时接受了评估;12.8%能够独立行走,18.4%需要支撑行走。成功行走的独立预测因素包括早期运动里程碑,如与2岁时不会翻身相比的坐立(优势比:12.5;95%置信区间:5.8 - 27.2)和拉着站立(优势比:28.5;95%置信区间:13.4 - 60.4)、痉挛性四肢瘫以外的脑瘫类型(优势比:2.2;95%置信区间:1.5 - 3.1)以及保留的视觉功能(优势比:2.4;95%置信区间:1.1 - 5.4)。我们的行走图表描绘了在14岁之前所有后续年龄段保持不能行走、转变为三种可能行走状态之一或死亡的概率。
行走图表提供了一种简单直接的方法来估计2至3.5岁不能行走的脑瘫患儿最终在有或没有支撑的情况下行走的概率。