Mariño Rodrigo J, Stuart Geoffrey W, Winning Tracey, Morgan Michael V, Thomson W Murray, Marshall Roderick I, Gotjamanos Theo
School of Health, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351 Australia.
J Dent Educ. 2004 Nov;68(11):1178-84.
The objective of this study was to examine the value orientations of dental students from different ethnic backgrounds studying in Australian dental schools. A ninety-eight-item questionnaire was used to collect the data, including fifteen subscales developed consistent with the Kluckhohn and Strodtbeck value orientation model. To compare the value orientation structure and to determine if any ethnic differences existed, a multivariate analysis of variance called profile analysis was performed on the fifteen value subscales. Of the 401 participants, 30.2 percent were Anglo-Australian and 44.9 percent were Asian. The remainder (24.9 percent) were "Other-background residents" or "Other-international students." This article presents data from Asian (n=184) and Anglo-Australian (n=124) background respondents. Mean age was 21.7 years (s.e. 0.35 years) among Anglo-Australian and 20.8 years (s.e. 0.17 years) among Asians. Asians born overseas represented 70.7 percent (n=130) of this group. Of Australia-born Asians (n=54), 90.6 percent were first-generation Australians. When comparing their value profile, we found a significant association between ethnicity and value orientation profile scores (p<0.05). Despite the significant overall result, the strength of the association (eta(2)=0.007) indicated that this effect was trivial relative to the unexplained variance in value orientation. The findings suggest that, behind an apparent ethnic diversity, a single distinctive value profile might exist to which the majority of dental students subscribe.
本研究的目的是调查在澳大利亚牙科学院学习的不同种族背景的牙科学生的价值取向。使用一份包含98个条目的问卷来收集数据,其中包括根据克拉克洪和施特德贝克价值取向模型制定的15个子量表。为了比较价值取向结构并确定是否存在任何种族差异,对这15个价值子量表进行了一种称为轮廓分析的多变量方差分析。在401名参与者中,30.2%是英裔澳大利亚人,44.9%是亚洲人。其余(24.9%)是“其他背景居民”或“其他国际学生”。本文展示了来自亚洲(n = 184)和英裔澳大利亚(n = 124)背景受访者的数据。英裔澳大利亚人的平均年龄为21.7岁(标准误0.35岁),亚洲人的平均年龄为20.8岁(标准误0.17岁)。该群体中出生在海外的亚洲人占70.7%(n = 130)。在出生于澳大利亚的亚洲人(n = 54)中,90.6%是第一代澳大利亚人。在比较他们的价值轮廓时,我们发现种族与价值取向轮廓得分之间存在显著关联(p<0.05)。尽管总体结果显著,但关联强度(η² = 0.007)表明,相对于价值取向中无法解释的方差,这种影响微不足道。研究结果表明,在明显的种族多样性背后,可能存在一个大多数牙科学生认同的独特价值轮廓。