Shapiro Jason S, Bessette Michael J, Baumlin Kevin M, Ragin Deborah Fish, Richardson Lynne D
Mount Sinai School of Medicine, 1 Gustave L. Levy Place, Box 1620, New York, NY 10029, USA.
Acad Emerg Med. 2004 Nov;11(11):1223-8. doi: 10.1197/j.aem.2004.08.017.
This article reviews the capabilities, advantages, and disadvantages of three forms of automated data collection-scannable data forms, Web-based forms, and handheld computers-compared with the current standard of data entry by hand on paper forms. Each of these methods is reviewed with respect to ease of use, experience required of designer, end-user training requirements, costs, flexibility, speed, accuracy/error rate, potential for data loss, need for technical support, and equipment and/or software requirements. A discussion of their appropriate application to various kinds of studies is included, followed by examples of research studies using each of these methods.
本文回顾了三种自动数据收集形式——可扫描数据表单、基于网络的表单和手持计算机——与当前在纸质表单上手写数据录入标准相比的功能、优点和缺点。针对每种方法,从易用性、设计者所需经验、终端用户培训要求、成本、灵活性、速度、准确性/错误率、数据丢失可能性、技术支持需求以及设备和/或软件要求等方面进行了评估。文中还讨论了它们在各类研究中的适当应用,并列举了使用每种方法的研究实例。