Mahmood T A, Dick M J, Smith N C, Templeton A A
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Aberdeen Maternity Hospital, UK.
Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1992 Feb;99(2):112-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-0528.1992.tb14466.x.
To compare conservative versus prostaglandin management of prelabour rupture of the membranes (PROM) in healthy primigravid women at term.
A prospective randomized study.
Labour Ward, Aberdeen Maternity Hospital.
230 primigravidae at terms with PROM, 115 allocated to be treated conservatively and 115 to be managed with prostaglandin treatment.
In the conservatively managed group the women were observed for up to 24 h after hospital admission with PROM. The actively managed group had PGE2 gel (2 mg) instilled into the posterior fornix and if contractions had not commenced, a further dose of PGE2 gel (1 mg) was instilled 6 h later. In both groups, if labour had not established 24 h after admission, intravenous oxytocin was given in escalating doses.
PROM to delivery interval, oxytocin augmentation, mode of delivery, maternal and neonatal infective morbidity.
There was a significant reduction in the PROM to delivery interval in the women managed actively with PGE2 gel and fewer women in the PGE2 group required oxytocin augmentation (31% vs 51%). The two managements groups were comparable for intrapartum analgesia, antibiotic treatment, babies requiring admission to the special care nursery unit and delivery by caesarean section.
The early use of prostaglandin is associated with a significant reduction in PROM to delivery interval without a significant increase in infective morbidity or caesarean section rate. However, the advantages of the conservative approach should not be overlooked. More work is still needed in the management of those women where uterine activity fails to establish within 24 h after PROM.
比较足月健康初产妇胎膜早破(PROM)的保守治疗与前列腺素治疗。
前瞻性随机研究。
阿伯丁妇产医院产房。
230例足月胎膜早破初产妇,115例分配至保守治疗组,115例分配至前列腺素治疗组。
保守治疗组产妇入院后胎膜早破观察长达24小时。积极治疗组将PGE2凝胶(2毫克)注入后穹窿,若未开始宫缩,6小时后再注入一剂PGE2凝胶(1毫克)。两组中,若入院后24小时未临产,则递增剂量静脉滴注缩宫素。
胎膜早破至分娩间隔、缩宫素引产、分娩方式、母婴感染发病率。
积极使用PGE2凝胶治疗的产妇胎膜早破至分娩间隔显著缩短,PGE2组需要缩宫素引产的产妇较少(31%对51%)。两组在产时镇痛、抗生素治疗、需入住特殊护理病房的婴儿以及剖宫产分娩方面具有可比性。
早期使用前列腺素可显著缩短胎膜早破至分娩间隔,且感染发病率和剖宫产率无显著增加。然而,保守治疗方法的优势也不应被忽视。对于胎膜早破后24小时内子宫活动未启动的产妇,仍需要开展更多研究。