Ahmed Sofia B, Grace Sherry L, Stelfox Henry T, Tomlinson George, Cheung Angela M
Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Can J Cardiol. 2004 Nov;20(13):1351-4.
Despite increasing numbers of female medical school graduates, few women enter cardiovascular specialties. Pharmaceutical promotion may influence physician behaviour. It is unclear how female physicians are represented in cardiovascular advertisements, which may, in turn, influence physician perceptions.
To determine if female and male physicians are equally represented in cardiovascular advertisements.
All cardiovascular advertisements from American editions of general medical and cardiovascular journals published between January 1, 1996, and June 30, 1998, were examined. For each unique advertisement, the total number of journal appearances and the number of appearances in journals' premium positions were recorded. The role, sex, age and race of the primary figure featured in the advertisement were noted.
Nine hundred nineteen unique advertisements were identified, 35 of which depicted a physician as the primary figure. Six (17%, 95% CI 8.1% to 32.7%) of these advertisements portrayed a female physician, while 29 (83%, 95% CI 67.3% to 91.9%) depicted a male physician (P<0.001). Female physician advertisements appeared in journals 39 times (20.7%; 95% CI 2.8% to 43.5%), while male physician advertisements appeared 149 times (79.3%; 95% CI 56.5% to 97.2%) (P=0.01). The odds ratio for a female physician advertisement appearing in a premium position compared with a male physician advertisement was 0.25 (95% CI 0.09 to 0.68).
The relative paucity of female physicians in cardiovascular advertisements is a concern because it may both reflect and reinforce sex asymmetries in cardiovascular specialties.
尽管医学院女毕业生人数不断增加,但进入心血管专业领域的女性却寥寥无几。医药推广可能会影响医生的行为。目前尚不清楚心血管广告中女性医生的呈现情况,而这反过来可能会影响医生的认知。
确定心血管广告中男女医生的呈现比例是否相同。
对1996年1月1日至1998年6月30日期间美国出版的综合医学和心血管医学期刊中的所有心血管广告进行审查。对于每一则独特的广告,记录其在期刊上出现的总次数以及在期刊优质版面出现的次数。记录广告中主要人物的角色、性别、年龄和种族。
共识别出919则独特的广告,其中35则以医生作为主要人物。这些广告中有6则(17%,95%可信区间8.1%至32.7%)描绘了女性医生,而29则(83%,95%可信区间67.3%至91.9%)描绘了男性医生(P<0.001)。女性医生广告在期刊上出现了39次(20.7%;95%可信区间2.8%至43.5%),而男性医生广告出现了149次(79.3%;95%可信区间56.5%至97.2%)(P=0.01)。与男性医生广告相比,女性医生广告出现在优质版面的比值比为0.25(95%可信区间0.09至0.68)。
心血管广告中女性医生相对较少令人担忧,因为这可能既反映了又强化了心血管专业领域的性别不对称。