Chaillet Nils, Nyström Marjatta, Kataja Matti, Demirjian Arto
Université de Montreal, département d'anthropologie, unité d'anthropologie physique, C.P. 6128, succursale Centre-Ville, Montréal, Québec, H3C3J7 Canada.
J Forensic Sci. 2004 Nov;49(6):1324-31.
Dental maturity was studied from 2213 dental panoramic radiographs of healthy ethnic Finns from southern Finland, aged between 2 and 19 years. The aim was to provide new Finnish maturity tables and curves and to compare the efficiency of Demirjian's method when differently weighted scores and polynomial regressions are used. The inter-ethnic variations lead us to calculate specific Finnish weighted scores. Demirjian's method gives maturity score as a function of age and seems better adapted for clinicians because, in their case, the maturity score is unknown. Polynomial functions give age as a function of maturity score and are statically adapted for age estimation studies. Finnish dental maturity tables and development curves are given for Demirjian's method and for polynomial functions. Sexual dimorphism is established for the same weighted score for girls and boys, and girls present a greater maturity than boys for all of age groups. Polynomial functions are highly reliable (0.19% of misclassifies) and the percentile method, using Finnish weighted scores, is very accurate (+/- 1.95 years on average, between 2 and 18 years of age). This suggests that polynomial functions are most useful in forensic sciences, while Demirjian's method is most useful for dental health clinicians.
我们对来自芬兰南部、年龄在2至19岁之间的2213名健康芬兰族裔的牙科全景X光片进行了牙齿成熟度研究。目的是提供新的芬兰成熟度表格和曲线,并比较使用不同加权分数和多项式回归时德米尔坚方法的效率。种族间差异促使我们计算特定的芬兰加权分数。德米尔坚方法根据年龄给出成熟度分数,似乎更适合临床医生,因为在他们的情况下,成熟度分数是未知的。多项式函数根据成熟度分数给出年龄,在统计学上适用于年龄估计研究。给出了德米尔坚方法和多项式函数的芬兰牙齿成熟度表格及发育曲线。确定了女孩和男孩相同加权分数下的性别差异,并且在所有年龄组中女孩的成熟度都高于男孩。多项式函数高度可靠(错误分类率为0.19%),使用芬兰加权分数的百分位数法非常准确(2至18岁之间平均误差为±1.95岁)。这表明多项式函数在法医学中最有用,而德米尔坚方法对牙科健康临床医生最有用。