Department of Imaging & Pathology, Forensic Odontology, KU Leuven Campus Saint Raphael 7, Block A, Box 7001, Leuven, 3000, Belgium.
Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Orthodontics, Institute of Dentistry, University of Turku, Turku, Finland.
Int J Legal Med. 2024 Nov;138(6):2441-2457. doi: 10.1007/s00414-024-03279-z. Epub 2024 Jul 29.
The timing of dental development in ethnic Finns and Somalis, who were born and living in Finland, was compared, with efforts to minimize environmental bias. The developmental status of seven lower left permanent teeth were staged according to Demirjian et al., using panoramic radiographs from 2,100 Finnish and 808 Somali females and males, aged 2 to 23 years. For each tooth, a continuation-ratio model was constructed to analyze the allocated stages as a function of sex and ethnic origin. Several statistically significant differences in mean age of certain tooth developmental stage transitions were revealed. While Somalis generally displayed stage transitions at younger age, none of the seven teeth consistently showed earlier stage transitions in Somalis compared to Finns. Within each tooth, the lowest (or highest) mean age of stage transition varied without any discernible pattern between the two ethnic groups. Overall, the observed differences in mean age of stage transition between the groups was minimal, suggesting a low impact on clinical and forensic age assessment practice. In conclusion, the studied ethnic Finn and Somali groups with equal nutritional and /or environmental conditions exhibit similar timing in the development of all lower left permanent teeth.
本研究旨在比较出生并居住在芬兰的芬兰裔和索马里裔人群的牙齿发育时间,以尽量减少环境偏差。使用来自 2100 名芬兰女性和 808 名索马里女性和男性的全景 X 光片,根据 Demirjian 等人的方法对 7 颗左下恒牙的发育阶段进行分期。对于每颗牙齿,构建连续比模型,分析性别和种族对分配阶段的影响。结果显示,在某些牙齿发育阶段的转变中,平均年龄存在几个统计学上显著的差异。尽管索马里人通常在较小的年龄显示出阶段转变,但与芬兰人相比,在七颗牙齿中,没有一颗牙齿的阶段转变始终更早。在每个牙齿中,最低(或最高)阶段转变的平均年龄在两个种族群体之间没有任何明显的模式变化。总体而言,两组之间阶段转变平均年龄的观察差异很小,这表明对临床和法医年龄评估实践的影响很小。结论是,在营养和/或环境条件相同的情况下,研究中的芬兰裔和索马里裔族群在所有左下恒牙的发育时间上表现出相似的时间。