Mullins C Daniel, Snyder Stephen E, Wang Junling, Cooke Jesse L, Baquet Claudia
University of Maryland School of Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Health Services Research Department, 515 W. Lombard St., Second Floor, Baltimore MD 21201, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2004 Dec;96(12):1565-74.
Cancer is the second leading cause of death in the United States and a major contributor to healthcare expenditure. There are few studies examining disparities in treatment costs. Studies that do exist are dominated by the cost of hospital care.
Utilizing Maryland Medicaid administrative claims data, a retrospective cohort, design was employed to examine disparities in ambulatory treatment costs of breast, colorectal and prostate cancer treatment by region, race and gender. We report mean and median results by each demographic category and test for the statistical significance of each. Lorenz curves are plotted and Gini coefficients calculated for each type of cancer.
We do not find a consistent trend in ambulatory costs across the three cancers by traditional demographic variables. Lorenz curves indicate highly unequal distributions of costs. Gini coefficients are 0.687 for breast cancer, 0.757 for colorectal cancer and 0.774 for prostate cancer.
Significant variation in nonhospital-based expenditures exists for breast, colorectal and prostate cancers in a population of homogeneous socioeconomic status and uniform insurance entitlement. Observed individual-level disparities are not consistent across cancers by region, race or gender, but the majority of this low-income population receives very little ambulatory care.
癌症是美国第二大死因,也是医疗保健支出的主要构成因素。很少有研究探讨治疗成本方面的差异。现有的研究主要关注医院护理成本。
利用马里兰州医疗补助管理索赔数据,采用回顾性队列设计,按地区、种族和性别研究乳腺癌、结直肠癌和前列腺癌门诊治疗成本的差异。我们报告了各人口类别对应的均值和中位数结果,并检验了各自的统计显著性。绘制了洛伦兹曲线,并计算了每种癌症的基尼系数。
根据传统人口统计学变量,我们未发现这三种癌症的门诊成本存在一致趋势。洛伦兹曲线表明成本分布高度不平等。乳腺癌的基尼系数为0.687,结直肠癌为0.757,前列腺癌为0.774。
在社会经济地位相同且享有统一保险权益的人群中,乳腺癌、结直肠癌和前列腺癌的非医院支出存在显著差异。观察到的个体层面差异在不同癌症中因地区、种族或性别而异,但大多数低收入人群接受的门诊护理很少。