Bartha J L, Romero-Carmona R, Martínez-Del-Fresno P, Comino-Delgado R
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University Hospital of Puerto Real, Puerto Real, Cadiz, Spain.
Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2005 Feb;25(2):155-9. doi: 10.1002/uog.1813.
To compare transvaginal ultrasound with the Bishop score in assessment of cervical ripening for choice of induction agent.
Eighty women were randomized to have preinduction cervical assessment for choice of induction agent based on either Bishop score or transvaginal ultrasound. The primary outcome measure was the percentage of women who were administered prostaglandin as a preinduction agent. The criteria for considering the cervix as unripe and thus for using prostaglandin were either a Bishop score < 6 or a cervical length > 30 mm with cervical wedging of < 30% of the total cervical length. Secondary outcome measures included interval to active phase, interval to delivery and rate of Cesarean section.
While 85% of women received prostaglandin in the Bishop score group, only 50% of them did in the transvaginal ultrasound group (P = 0.001). The interval to active phase, interval to delivery and rate of Cesarean section were similar in both groups.
With the suggested cut-off values of a Bishop score < 6 or a cervical length > 30 mm and wedging < 30%, the use of transvaginal ultrasound instead of Bishop score for preinduction cervical assessment to choose induction agent significantly reduces the need for intracervical prostaglandin treatment without adversely affecting the success of induction.
比较经阴道超声与Bishop评分在评估宫颈成熟度以选择引产药物方面的差异。
80名女性被随机分组,根据Bishop评分或经阴道超声进行引产术前宫颈评估以选择引产药物。主要观察指标是接受前列腺素作为引产术前用药的女性比例。将宫颈视为未成熟从而使用前列腺素的标准为Bishop评分<6或宫颈长度>30mm且宫颈楔入度<宫颈总长度的30%。次要观察指标包括进入活跃期的时间间隔、分娩时间间隔和剖宫产率。
在Bishop评分组中,85%的女性接受了前列腺素治疗,而在经阴道超声组中,这一比例仅为50%(P = 0.001)。两组进入活跃期的时间间隔、分娩时间间隔和剖宫产率相似。
采用Bishop评分<6或宫颈长度>30mm且楔入度<30%的建议临界值,使用经阴道超声而非Bishop评分进行引产术前宫颈评估以选择引产药物,可显著减少宫颈内前列腺素治疗的需求,且不会对引产成功率产生不利影响。