Padosch Stephan A, Schmidt Peter H, Schyma Christian, Hirsch Rolf D, Kröner Lars U, Dettmeyer Reinhard B, Madea Burkhard
Institut für Rechtsmedizin der Universität Bonn.
Arch Kriminol. 2004 Nov-Dec;214(5-6):149-62.
The second part of the paper on suicides by gunshots to the head in the presence of witnesses focuses on relevant morphological autopsy findings such as entrance site, signs of close range or contact shots, bullet path etc. and also discusses selected aspects of ascertaining gunshot residues. For the identification of the shooter an integral medicolegal assessment of all the facts including the investigation results and the autopsy findings is essential. However, the morphological findings alone do not allow safe diagnosis, as for example in a homicide the temporal region, which was affected in all our cases, may have been deliberately chosen by the perpetrator as a localization typical of suicide. Thus methods to ascertain gunshot residues on the firing hand (by means of adhesive films and the polyvinyl-alcohol collection method--PVAL) are of great practical importance. In seven cases adhesive films and/or the polyvinyl-alcohol collection method were used. In one case the gunshot residues (GSR) were analysed by means of tape lifts and subsequent scanning electron microscopy (SEM). It was found that especially the combined application of topographical (adhesive tape/PVAL) and cumulative (SEM) methods allowed for the doubtless identification of the shooter, thus usually confirming the suicide. By the example of one case it is demonstrated that without the immediate collection of evidence at the scene objective reconstruction of the event becomes impossible. On the basis of the reported cases recommendations are finally given for a differentiated approach in the medicolegal evaluation of alleged witnessed suicide by gunshot (to the head).
该论文的第二部分聚焦于有目击者在场情况下头部枪伤自杀事件,着重探讨了相关的形态学尸检结果,如入口位置、近距离射击或接触射击的迹象、子弹路径等,还讨论了确定枪击残留物的某些方面。为了识别枪手,对包括调查结果和尸检结果在内的所有事实进行全面的法医学评估至关重要。然而,仅凭形态学发现无法做出可靠诊断,例如在杀人案件中,我们所有案例中受影响的颞部区域,可能是犯罪者故意选择的典型自杀部位。因此,确定射击手上枪击残留物的方法(通过粘贴膜和聚乙烯醇收集法——PVAL)具有重要的实际意义。在七个案例中使用了粘贴膜和/或聚乙烯醇收集法。在一个案例中,通过胶带提取和随后的扫描电子显微镜(SEM)对枪击残留物(GSR)进行了分析。结果发现,特别是地形学方法(胶带/PVAL)和累积方法(SEM)的联合应用能够毫无疑问地识别枪手,从而通常能证实自杀情况。通过一个案例表明,如果不在现场立即收集证据,就不可能对事件进行客观重建。基于所报告的案例,最后针对所谓有目击者在场的头部枪伤自杀事件的法医学评估给出了差异化方法的建议。