Schyma P, Schyma C
Labor für experimentelle Ballistik, Hürth.
Versicherungsmedizin. 1997 Aug 1;49(4):112-7.
Gunshot residues on the hand are an important evidence of shooting. Different methods for sampling gunshot residues from the hands are presented and critically analyzed. The topographic methods-adhesive film and polyvinyl alcohol technique (PVAL)-have serious advantages over the cumulative methods like tape-lift or cotton swab. Case examples demonstrate the limited interpretation of results with cumulative methods. Negative results of tape-lifts or cotton swabs can also be explained by the presence of blood or dirt, positive results however don't prove shooting. The sampling method with the highest gain of gunshot residues is the PVAL technique which takes about 2 hours of sampling traces. Therefore PVAL is mostly applied post mortem. PVAL shows the distribution of gunshot residues also on bloody hands and is a powerful instrument for the reconstruction of the firing position. But the final differentiation between homicide, suicide or accident is not only based on gunshot residues, but requires a complex analysis of all findings in a case (scene, blood traces, autopsy, shot range).
手上的枪击残留物是射击的重要证据。本文介绍并批判性地分析了从手上采集枪击残留物的不同方法。形貌法——粘贴膜法和聚乙烯醇技术(PVAL)——相对于胶带粘贴或棉签擦拭等累积法具有显著优势。案例表明累积法的结果解读存在局限性。胶带粘贴或棉签擦拭结果为阴性也可能是由于血液或污垢的存在,而阳性结果并不一定能证明发生过枪击。采集枪击残留物收获最大的采样方法是PVAL技术,该技术采集痕迹大约需要2小时。因此,PVAL大多在尸体解剖后应用。PVAL还能显示出血手上枪击残留物的分布情况,是重建射击位置的有力工具。但是,区分他杀、自杀或意外死亡不能仅基于枪击残留物,而是需要对案件中的所有调查结果(现场、血迹、尸检、射击距离)进行综合分析。