Kim Kwang Gi, Cho Seong Whi, Min Seon Jung, Kim Jong Hyo, Min Byoung Goo, Bae Kyongtae T
Interdisciplinary Program in Medical and Biological Engineering, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Acad Radiol. 2005 Jan;12(1):58-66. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2004.11.010.
To evaluate the ultrasonographic features of breast masses using a computerized scheme and to correlate the feature values with radiologists' grading.
One hundred and seventy-five breast ultrasound images (one to five images per subject) from 61 women (age 17-89 years, mean 43 years) were studied. Thirty-eight of the 157 images were from 11 women with malignant lesions, and the remaining 137 were from 50 patients with benign lesions. Two breast imaging radiologists participated in an observer performance study and were asked to grade, on a scale of 3, shape (1: regular, 3: very irregular), border (1: sharp, 3: ill-defined), internal texture (1: homogeneous, 3: very heterogeneous), width/depth ratio (1: flat, 3: tall), posterior enhancement (1: strong, 3: none), and lateral shadowing (1: strong, 3: none). The computerized scheme analyzed the breast region within a region of interest that was placed by a radiologist and quantified the following parameters: shape (jag count, disperse, convex hull depth, and lobulation count), border (acutance, average maximum ascending gradient, and sigmoid curve fitting), texture (edge density, co-occurrence matrix, and fractal dimension), width-depth ratio, posterior enhancement, and lateral shadowing. Correlations between the radiologists and the computerized scheme for assessing parameters in corresponding categories were computed.
Good agreement was seen in posterior enhancement (P < .001, r = 0.45), lateral shadowing (P < .001, r = 0.38), width-depth ratio (P < .001, r = 0.33), and shape features (all P < .001): jag count (r = 0.38), disperseness (r = 0.55), and convex hull depth (r = 0.44). The remaining parameters demonstrated a poor or weak correlation (r < 0.30).
The radiologists and the computerized scheme correlated best in analysis of shape features and posterior enhancement. We have yet to determine the significance of these features for the implementation of a computer-aided diagnosis program for characterizing breast ultrasound masses.
使用计算机化方案评估乳腺肿块的超声特征,并将特征值与放射科医生的分级相关联。
研究了61名女性(年龄17 - 89岁,平均43岁)的175幅乳腺超声图像(每位受试者1至5幅图像)。157幅图像中的38幅来自11名患有恶性病变的女性,其余137幅来自50名患有良性病变的患者。两名乳腺影像放射科医生参与了观察者性能研究,并被要求按3分制对形状(1:规则,3:极不规则)、边界(1:清晰,3:边界不清)、内部纹理(1:均匀,3:极不均匀)、宽/深比(1:扁平,3:高)、后方增强(1:强,3:无)和侧方声影(1:强,3:无)进行分级。计算机化方案分析了放射科医生放置的感兴趣区域内的乳腺区域,并对以下参数进行量化:形状(锯齿计数、离散度、凸包深度和分叶计数)、边界(锐度、平均最大上升梯度和S形曲线拟合)、纹理(边缘密度、共生矩阵和分形维数)、宽深比、后方增强和侧方声影。计算了放射科医生与计算机化方案在评估相应类别参数方面的相关性。
在后方增强(P <.001,r = 0.45)、侧方声影(P <.001,r = 0.38)、宽深比(P <.001,r = 0.33)和形状特征(均P <.001)方面观察到良好的一致性:锯齿计数(r = 0.38)、离散度(r = 0.55)和凸包深度(r = 0.44)。其余参数显示出较差或较弱的相关性(r < 0.30)。
放射科医生与计算机化方案在形状特征和后方增强分析方面相关性最佳。我们尚未确定这些特征对于实施用于乳腺超声肿块特征化的计算机辅助诊断程序的意义。