Lee B B, Kim Y W, Seo J M, Hwang J H, Do Y S, Kim D I, Byun H S, Lee S K, Huh S H, Hyun W S
Department of Surgery, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine and Samsung Medical Center, Seoul, Korea.
Vasc Endovascular Surg. 2005 Jan-Feb;39(1):67-81. doi: 10.1177/153857440503900107.
A lymphatic malformation (LM) is the most common form of congenital vascular malformation (CVM). The new Hamburg classification of CVM distinguishes the truncular (T) form from the extratruncular (ET) form of LMs. Both are consequences of a developmental arrest at the different stages of lymphangiogenesis as a result of defective genes. The purpose of this review was to evaluate the current management results of both forms of LMs. A retrospective review of the clinical data of 315 patients with a diagnosis of LMs treated between September 1994 and December 2001 was performed. Lymphoscintigraphy was the most frequent diagnostic test. The patients with the ET form were treated with sclerotherapy with OK-432 and/or ethanol. Combinations of CDP (complex decongestive physiotherapy) and/or compressotherapy were used to treat all the T-form patients. In addition, surgery, either reconstructive or ablative, was offered to patients with the T form who failed to respond to the proper CDP. A multidisciplinary team performed the management of LM, and the results were evaluated every 6 months. Among 797 patients with CVM, 315 were confirmed to have LMs, either as the T form (226) or the ET form (89). Another 66 LMs were diagnosed with hemolymphatic malformations (HLM). Most of the ET forms (89/315) were the cystic type (70/89), while the T forms included aplasia and/or an obstruction (204/226). The ET form was most frequent in the head, neck, and thorax (69/89). The T form was located most frequently to the extremities (202/226), mostly to the lower limb (180/202). Two hundred and twenty-six T forms belonged to the various clinical stages: stages I-32, II-104, III-48, IV-18, and an unclear stage-24. The ET form was treated with sclerotherapy using OK-432 (108/120) and absolute ethanol (12/120). Among the 11 patients with the multiple ET form, 7 patients underwent perioperative sclerotherapy with OK-432 and a subsequent surgical excision. The clinical response of the T form at the extremity to CDP was excellent to good in a majority of clinical stages I to II (121/136) but decreased to a good to fair degree in stages III to IV (31/66). The additional surgical therapy, either reconstructive (10/19) or ablative (9/19), provided limited success in improving CDP efficacy, owing mainly to poor compliance. The long-term outcome of the initial success through self-motivated home-maintenance care during the follow-up period of up to 48 months was totally dependent on patient compliance. OK-432 sclerotherapy to 51 ET forms has shown excellent results on 88.9% of the cystic type (40/45) and 50% (3/6) of the cavernous type (minimum follow-up for 24 months). Seventeen ET forms in 7 patients were treated with a preoperative OK-432 sclerotherapy and a subsequent surgical excision, which provided good to excellent results in 14 for a minimum of 24 months. Primary lymphedema, which is the T form of LMs, can be managed safely by a combination of CDP with compressotherapy. Patients with good compliance can benefit from additional surgical therapy, either reconstructive or ablative. The ET form, particularly the cystic type, can be treated with various scleroagents that are preferably less toxic as the primary therapy. A surgical excision with or without perioperative sclerotherapy provides good results for patients with the localized cavernous type of the ET form. A multidisciplinary team approach is essential for the proper care of LM.
淋巴管畸形(LM)是先天性血管畸形(CVM)最常见的形式。新的汉堡CVM分类将LM的主干型(T型)与主干外型(ET型)区分开来。两者都是由于基因缺陷导致淋巴管生成不同阶段发育停滞的结果。本综述的目的是评估这两种类型LM的当前治疗效果。对1994年9月至2001年12月间诊断为LM的315例患者的临床资料进行了回顾性研究。淋巴闪烁造影是最常用的诊断检查。ET型患者采用OK-432和/或乙醇硬化治疗。所有T型患者均采用综合消肿物理治疗(CDP)和/或压迫治疗联合治疗。此外,对于对适当的CDP治疗无反应的T型患者,提供重建或切除手术。一个多学科团队对LM进行管理,并每6个月评估一次结果。在797例CVM患者中,315例确诊为LM,其中T型226例,ET型89例。另外66例LM被诊断为血淋巴管畸形(HLM)。大多数ET型(89/315)为囊性(70/89),而T型包括发育不全和/或梗阻(204/226)。ET型最常见于头、颈和胸部(69/89)。T型最常位于四肢(202/226),主要在下肢(180/202)。226例T型属于不同临床阶段:I期32例,II期104例,III期48例,IV期18例,分期不明24例。ET型采用OK-432硬化治疗(108/120)和无水乙醇硬化治疗(12/120)。在11例多发型ET型患者中,7例患者在围手术期采用OK-432硬化治疗,随后进行手术切除。T型肢体对CDP的临床反应在大多数I至II期临床阶段为优至良(121/136),但在III至IV期降至良至中(31/66)。额外的手术治疗,无论是重建性(10/19)还是切除性(9/19),在提高CDP疗效方面取得的成功有限,主要原因是依从性差。在长达48个月的随访期内,通过自我激励的家庭维持护理取得初步成功的长期结果完全取决于患者的依从性。对51例ET型进行OK-432硬化治疗,结果显示88.9%的囊性型(40/45)和50%的海绵状型(3/6)效果极佳(最短随访24个月)。7例患者的17例ET型采用术前OK-432硬化治疗,随后进行手术切除,其中14例至少随访24个月,效果良好至极佳。原发性淋巴水肿即LM的T型,可通过CDP与压迫治疗联合安全管理。依从性好的患者可从额外的重建或切除手术治疗中获益。ET型,尤其是囊性型,可采用毒性较低的各种硬化剂作为主要治疗方法。对于局限性海绵状型ET型患者,手术切除联合或不联合围手术期硬化治疗效果良好。多学科团队方法对于LM的恰当治疗至关重要。