Theriot Matthew T, Segal Steven P
University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee 37996-3333, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2005 Feb;56(2):179-85. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.56.2.179.
This study assessed involvement with the criminal justice system among new clients of community mental health centers and self-help agencies in order to determine the characteristics and service needs of this population. Such information has implications for improving the care available for persons with mental illness who have been involved with the criminal justice system.
Interview assessments and criminal records were obtained for 673 new clients of 21 outpatient mental health agencies. Descriptive statistics, chi square tests, and multivariate analysis of variance were used to describe these new help-seekers and their involvement with the criminal justice system.
A total of 303 study participants (45 percent) had at least one contact with the criminal justice system before arriving at the agency, with an approximately equal percentage at community mental health centers and self-help agencies. The mean+/-SD number of contacts with the criminal justice system was 7.81+/-9.12. A total of 240 individuals (36 percent) had at least one criminal conviction, including 128 (19 percent) with a felony conviction. Common charges and convictions included petty theft, assault and battery, felony theft, narcotics offenses, and misdemeanor drug offenses. Clients who had been involved with the criminal justice system were more likely to be homeless, to have drug dependence, to have greater psychological disability, and to have less personal empowerment than other clients.
The population overlap between the mental health system and criminal justice system and the multiple problems facing criminally involved clients argues for greater collaboration between the two systems and a comprehensive package of services to meet the multiple needs of this population. The equal distribution of these individuals and similar offense patterns at both types of agencies necessitates further consideration of the role that nontraditional service providers have in serving individuals with a history of involvement with the criminal justice system.
本研究评估了社区心理健康中心和自助机构新客户与刑事司法系统的接触情况,以确定该人群的特征和服务需求。此类信息对于改善为涉及刑事司法系统的精神疾病患者提供的护理具有重要意义。
获取了21家门诊心理健康机构673名新客户的访谈评估和犯罪记录。采用描述性统计、卡方检验和多变量方差分析来描述这些新的求助者及其与刑事司法系统的接触情况。
共有303名研究参与者(45%)在到达机构之前至少与刑事司法系统有过一次接触,在社区心理健康中心和自助机构中的比例大致相等。与刑事司法系统接触的平均次数±标准差为7.81±9.12。共有240人(36%)至少有一项刑事定罪,其中128人(19%)为重罪定罪。常见指控和定罪包括小额盗窃、殴打、重罪盗窃、毒品犯罪和轻罪毒品犯罪。与刑事司法系统有过接触的客户比其他客户更有可能无家可归、有药物依赖、心理残疾程度更高且个人赋权更少。
心理健康系统与刑事司法系统之间的人群重叠以及涉及犯罪的客户面临的多重问题表明,这两个系统之间需要加强合作,并提供一套全面的服务以满足该人群的多种需求。这些个体在两类机构中的均等分布以及相似的犯罪模式,有必要进一步考虑非传统服务提供者在为有刑事司法系统接触史的个体提供服务方面所起的作用。