Tamarit-Borrás Meritxell, Delgado-Molina Esther, Berini-Aytés Leonardo, Gay-Escoda Cosme
Facultad de Odontología, Universidad de Barcelona, Barcelona.
Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal. 2005 Mar-Apr;10(2):151-62.
Based on our accumulated experience, the present study evaluates and discusses the indications, advantages and inconveniences of oral cavity epulis resection using the carbon dioxide laser (CO2) versus the Erbium:YAG laser (Er:YAG), diode laser and surgical scalpel.
A retrospective study has been made of 120 patients involving the removal of 128 epulis lesions with the CO2 laser, Er:YAG laser, diode laser and surgical scalpel. Postoperative controls were carried out after 7, 15 and 30 days to evaluate healing and wound evolution, and after 3, 6 and 12 months to assess possible relapse.
Two groups were defined, based on the clinical and etiopathogenic characteristics of the excised lesions: gingival hyperplastic lesions (77 cases) and fibromatous hyperplasia (51 cases). The lower jaw was the most frequent location of gingival hyperplasia (51.9%). Fibrous hyperplasia was the most common histological diagnosis (49 cases; 63.6%). Percentage relapse following removal was 9.1%, of which 5 cases corresponded to fibrous hyperplasia. Only one malignancy was identified, corresponding to infiltrating squamous cell carcinoma. On the other hand, of the 51 treated cases of fibromatous hyperplasia, 58.8% were located in the upper jaw. These were histologically confirmed to be fibrous hyperplasia, with relapse in 19.6% of the cases.
Although the different surgical techniques used for removal of epulis of the oral cavity are appropriate, we consider the CO2 laser to be the treatment of choice, since it offers a number of both intra- and postoperative advantages. On the other hand, all oral lesions require histological study to establish a firm diagnosis.
基于我们积累的经验,本研究评估并讨论使用二氧化碳激光(CO2)、铒钇铝石榴石激光(Er:YAG)、二极管激光和手术刀切除口腔龈瘤的适应症、优点和不便之处。
对120例患者进行了回顾性研究,这些患者使用CO2激光、Er:YAG激光、二极管激光和手术刀切除了128个龈瘤病变。术后分别在7天、15天和30天进行对照,以评估愈合情况和伤口演变,并在3个月、6个月和12个月后评估是否可能复发。
根据切除病变的临床和病因特征,将患者分为两组:牙龈增生性病变(77例)和纤维瘤样增生(51例)。下颌是牙龈增生最常见的部位(51.9%)。纤维增生是最常见的组织学诊断(49例;63.6%)。切除后的复发率为9.1%,其中5例为纤维增生。仅发现1例恶性肿瘤,为浸润性鳞状细胞癌。另一方面,在51例纤维瘤样增生治疗病例中,58.8%位于上颌。经组织学证实为纤维增生,19.6%的病例复发。
虽然用于切除口腔龈瘤的不同手术技术都是合适的,但我们认为CO2激光是首选治疗方法,因为它在术中及术后都有许多优点。另一方面,所有口腔病变都需要进行组织学研究以明确诊断。