Perry B D, Randolph T F
Epidemiology and Disease Control, International Livestock Research Institute, Nairobi, Kenya.
Dev Biol (Basel). 2004;119:389-402.
This paper discusses the role of integrated epidemiology and economics modelling in animal health planning, with particular reference to the evaluation of national level interventions that involve the vaccination of livestock. Well-integrated epidemiology and economics is considered essential if model outputs are to be of value in national animal disease control planning. The different approaches to the use of modelling in priority setting and resource allocation in animal health are reviewed and discussed. The authors conclude that this particular application of modelling is poorly developed, due in part to the complexities involved. Much more has been done to develop models that evaluate the merits of different intervention scenarios for a given single disease, and examples of these are presented. However, the authors conclude that despite the widespread use of such models, there is still considerable scope for the development of a more standardised approach, incorporating consideration of both direct and indirect implications of intervention options. In discussing the changing demands on animal health economics modelling, the authors propose that increased attention should be given to the valuation of "externalities", the calculation and interpretation of the distribution of costs and benefits, the evaluation of the impact of disease control on poverty reduction, and the development of real-time economics modelling techniques, to assist particularly in the effective management of disease outbreaks.
本文讨论了综合流行病学和经济学建模在动物健康规划中的作用,特别提及对涉及家畜疫苗接种的国家级干预措施的评估。如果模型输出结果要在国家动物疾病控制规划中具有价值,那么良好整合的流行病学和经济学被认为是必不可少的。本文回顾并讨论了在动物健康领域的优先级设定和资源分配中使用建模的不同方法。作者得出结论,由于其中涉及的复杂性,这种建模的特定应用发展不佳。在开发评估给定单一疾病不同干预方案优点的模型方面已经做了更多工作,并给出了这些模型的示例。然而,作者得出结论,尽管此类模型被广泛使用,但在开发一种更标准化的方法方面仍有相当大的空间,该方法应考虑干预选项的直接和间接影响。在讨论对动物健康经济学建模不断变化的需求时,作者提议应更多地关注“外部性”的估值、成本和效益分配的计算与解释、疾病控制对减贫影响的评估以及实时经济学建模技术的开发,以特别协助疾病爆发的有效管理。