Vanderwee Katrien, Grypdonck Maria H F, Defloor Tom
Nursing Science, Department of Public Health, Ghent University, UZ 2 Blok A, De Pintelaan 185, B 9000 Gent,
Age Ageing. 2005 May;34(3):261-7. doi: 10.1093/ageing/afi057. Epub 2005 Mar 11.
studies of the effectiveness of alternating pressure air mattresses (APAMs) for the prevention of pressure ulcers are scarce and in conflict.
evaluating whether an APAM is more or equally effective as the standard prevention.
randomised controlled trial.
patients admitted to 19 surgical, internal, or geriatric wards in seven Belgian hospitals were included if they were in need of prevention of pressure ulcers. To define this need, two methods were used randomly: the Braden Scale or the presence of non-blanchable erythema (NBE).
447 patients were randomised into either an experimental or a control group. In the experimental group, 222 patients were lying on an APAM (Alpha-X-Cell, Huntleigh Healthcare, UK). In the control group, 225 patients were lying on a visco-elastic foam mattress (Tempur, Tempur-World Inc., USA) in combination with turning every 4 hours. Both groups had identical sitting protocols.
there was no significant difference in incidence of pressure ulcers (grade 2-4) between the experimental (15.6%) and control group (15.3%) (P = 1). There were significantly more heel pressure ulcers in the control group (P = 0.006). There was an interaction effect between the risk assessment method and preventive measures for the development of all pressure ulcers and sacral pressure ulcers.
fewer patients developed heel pressure ulcers on an APAM. Patients identified as being in need of prevention based on the presence of NBE had a tendency to develop fewer pressure ulcers on an APAM. Patients identified as being in need of prevention, based on the Braden Scale, appeared to develop more sacral pressure ulcers on an APAM.
关于交替压力气垫床(APAM)预防压疮有效性的研究较少且存在矛盾。
评估APAM是否与标准预防措施同样有效或更有效。
随机对照试验。
比利时七家医院的19个外科、内科或老年病房收治的需要预防压疮的患者被纳入研究。为确定这种需求,随机采用两种方法:Braden量表或非苍白性红斑(NBE)的存在情况。
447例患者被随机分为试验组或对照组。试验组222例患者使用APAM(Alpha-X-Cell,英国Huntleigh Healthcare公司)。对照组225例患者使用粘弹性泡沫床垫(Tempur,美国Tempur-World公司)并每4小时翻身一次。两组的坐卧方案相同。
试验组(15.6%)和对照组(15.3%)的2-4级压疮发生率无显著差异(P = 1)。对照组的足跟压疮明显更多(P = 0.006)。在所有压疮和骶骨压疮的发生方面,风险评估方法与预防措施之间存在交互作用。
使用APAM时发生足跟压疮的患者较少。基于NBE的存在情况被确定需要预防的患者使用APAM时发生压疮的倾向较小。基于Braden量表被确定需要预防的患者使用APAM时似乎会发生更多的骶骨压疮。