Surowiec Scott M, Davies Mark G, Eberly Shirley W, Rhodes Jeffrey M, Illig Karl A, Shortell Cynthia K, Lee David E, Waldman David L, Green Richard M
Center for Vascular Disease, Division of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Rochester, NY 14642, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 2005 Feb;41(2):269-78. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2004.11.031.
The objectives of this study were to examine factors predictive of success or failure after percutaneous angioplasty (PTA) and stenting (S) of the superficial femoral artery (SFA) and to compare the results of PTA/S with a contemporary group of patients treated with femoropopliteal bypass.
A database of patients undergoing PTA and/or S of the SFA between 1986 and 2004 was maintained. Intention-to-treat analysis was performed. Patients underwent duplex scanning follow-up at 1, 3, and every 6 months after the intervention. Angiograms were reviewed in all cases to assess lesion characteristics and preprocedure and postprocedure runoff. Results were standardized to current TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus (TASC) and Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) criteria. Kaplan-Meier survival analyses were performed to assess time-dependent outcomes. Cox proportional hazard analyses were performed to assess factors associated with patient survival and treatment efficacy.
Three hundred eighty total limbs underwent PTA/S in 329 patients (67% male, 33% female; average age, 65 years). Mean follow-up was 1.8 years from the date of initial intervention. Indications for intervention were claudication in 66%, rest pain in 16%, and tissue loss in 18%. Runoff at the tibial level was 2.1 +/- 0.8 patent vessels. Mean SVS ischemia grade was 3.1 (range, 1 to 5). TASC lesion grades were A (48%), B (18%), C (22%), and D (12%). Angioplasty alone was used in 63% of cases. Primary treatment failure (inability to cross lesion) was seen in 7% of patients. There was one periprocedural death. Primary patency rates were 86% at 3 months, 80% at 6 months, 75% at 12 months, 66% at 24 months, 60% at 36 months, 58% at 48 months, and 52% at 60 months. Assisted primary patency rates were slightly higher ( P = not significant). By Cox proportional hazards analysis, patency of PTA/S was associated with higher preoperative ankle/brachial index ( P = .016) and the performance of angioplasty only ( P = .011). Failed or occluded PTA/S was associated with TASC C ( P < .0001) and TASC D lesions ( P < .0001). Patient death was associated with the presence of congestive heart failure ( P = .003). Subgroup analysis revealed that primary patency rates are highly dependent on lesion type (A > B > C > D, P < .0001). PTA/S patency for TASC A and B lesions compared favorably to prosthetic and venous femoropopliteal bypass. Surgical bypass was superior to PTA/S for TASC C and D lesions.
PTA and stenting of the SFA can be performed safely with excellent procedural success rates. Improved patency of these interventions was seen with increased ankle/brachial index and the performance of angioplasty only. Worse patency was seen with TASC C and TASC D lesions. Patency rates were strongly dependent on lesion type, and the results of angioplasty and stenting compared favorably with surgical bypass for TASC A and B lesions.
本研究的目的是检查预测股浅动脉(SFA)经皮血管成形术(PTA)和支架置入术(S)成败的因素,并将PTA/S的结果与同期接受股腘动脉旁路移植术的患者组进行比较。
维护了一个1986年至2004年间接受SFA的PTA和/或S的患者数据库。进行意向性分析。患者在干预后1、3和每6个月接受双功扫描随访。对所有病例的血管造影进行回顾,以评估病变特征以及术前和术后的血流情况。结果根据当前的跨大西洋跨学会共识(TASC)和血管外科学会(SVS)标准进行标准化。进行Kaplan-Meier生存分析以评估时间依赖性结果。进行Cox比例风险分析以评估与患者生存和治疗效果相关的因素。
329例患者(67%为男性,33%为女性;平均年龄65岁)的380条肢体接受了PTA/S。从初次干预日期起的平均随访时间为1.8年。干预的指征为间歇性跛行66%,静息痛16%,组织缺损18%。胫部水平的血流情况为2.1±0.8条通畅血管。平均SVS缺血分级为3.1(范围1至5)。TASC病变分级为A(48%)、B(18%)、C(22%)和D(12%)。63%的病例仅采用血管成形术。7%的患者出现初次治疗失败(无法通过病变部位)。围手术期有1例死亡。初次通畅率在3个月时为86%,6个月时为80%,12个月时为75%,24个月时为66%,36个月时为60%,48个月时为58%,60个月时为52%。辅助初次通畅率略高(P=无显著性差异)。通过Cox比例风险分析,PTA/S的通畅与较高的术前踝/臂指数(P=0.016)和仅进行血管成形术(P=0.011)相关。失败或闭塞的PTA/S与TASC C(P<0.0001)和TASC D病变(P<0.0001)相关。患者死亡与充血性心力衰竭的存在相关(P=0.003)。亚组分析显示,初次通畅率高度依赖于病变类型(A>B>C>D,P<为0.0001)。TASC A和B病变的PTA/S通畅情况与人工血管和静脉股腘动脉旁路移植术相比具有优势。对于TASC C和D病变,手术旁路优于PTA/S。
SFA的PTA和支架置入术可以安全地进行,手术成功率很高。随着踝/臂指数的增加和仅进行血管成形术,这些干预措施的通畅情况得到改善。TASC C和TASC D病变的通畅情况较差。通畅率强烈依赖于病变类型,对于TASC A和B病变,血管成形术和支架置入术的结果与手术旁路相比具有优势。