Nguyen Thanh H, Goss Kai-Uwe, Ball William P
Department of Geography and Environmental Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland 21218, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2005 Feb 15;39(4):913-24. doi: 10.1021/es048839s.
Values of the organic-carbon-based partition coefficient (Koc) have often been estimated using one-parameter linear free energy relationships (op-LFERs), which include both correlations between log Koc and log Kow, where Kow is the octanol-water partition coefficient, and op-LFERs that are based on first-order molecular connectivity indices. For chemicals with tendencies toward strong hydrogen-bonding or other specific interactions with the organic phase, however,these methods are notsufficientlyaccurate. Polyparameter LFERs (pp-LFERs) address these shortcomings by explicitly considering contributions toward free energy change from multiple kinds of molecular interactions with both water and bulk organic phases. This paper reviews pp-LFER theory and presents the development of a new pp-LFER for organic chemical partitioning with soil/sediment organic matter (SOM) using a data set of 356 carefully selected experimental values of log Koc for 75 chemicals, including apolar, monopolar, and bipolar compounds. The paradigm of representing SOM by a single pp-LFER is qualitatively supported by our results, and the set of coefficients for the regression log Koc= (1.10+/-0.10)E - (0.72+/-0.14)S + (0.15+/-0.15)A - (1.98+/-0.14)B + (2.28+/-0.14)V + (0.14+/-0.10) represents a proposed set of water-SOM-specific properties for estimating log Koc. The developed correlation outperformed other currently recommended approaches with the given Koc data set and also compared favorably against the use of new multiple class-specific op-LFER regressions. Overall, the pp-LFER approach is recommended over other current methods for the purpose of Koc estimation and especially for polar chemicals.
有机碳分配系数(Koc)的值通常使用单参数线性自由能关系(op-LFERs)来估算,其中包括log Koc与log Kow之间的相关性(Kow为正辛醇-水分配系数),以及基于一阶分子连接性指数的op-LFERs。然而,对于具有强氢键作用倾向或与有机相存在其他特定相互作用的化学品,这些方法的准确性不足。多参数LFERs(pp-LFERs)通过明确考虑多种与水和本体有机相的分子相互作用对自由能变化的贡献来解决这些缺点。本文综述了pp-LFER理论,并利用75种化学品(包括非极性、单极性和双极性化合物)的356个精心挑选的log Koc实验值数据集,提出了一种用于有机化学品在土壤/沉积物有机质(SOM)中分配的新pp-LFER。我们的结果在定性上支持了用单一pp-LFER表示SOM的范式,回归log Koc = (1.10±0.10)E - (0.72±0.14)S + (0.15±0.15)A - (1.98±0.14)B + (2.28±0.14)V + (0.14±0.10)的系数集代表了一组用于估算log Koc的水-SOM特定性质。在给定的Koc数据集上,所开发的相关性优于其他当前推荐的方法,并且与使用新的多类特定op-LFER回归相比也具有优势。总体而言,为了估算Koc,特别是对于极性化学品,推荐使用pp-LFER方法而非其他当前方法。