Mortensen Lynne
Department of Linguistics, Macquarie University, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2005 Apr-May;19(3):227-47. doi: 10.1080/02699200410001698652.
This qualitative study investigated written discourse in the form of personal letters written by ten people with aphasia following stroke and ten people with cognitive-language disorder as a consequence of traumatic brain injury, and compared their performance with 15 non brain-damaged writers. Personal letters perform the dual function of providing information and maintaining social relationships. Using the Systemic Functional Linguistics framework for investigation, letters were examined in terms of their dual functions, and at two different strata of language--generic structure and semantic organisation. A small quantum of research suggests that the dissociation between different strata of language (i.e., macro and micro linguistic abilities), identified in the spoken discourse of people with aphasia and people with cognitive-language disorder is mirrored in written discourse. Aphasic writers largely maintain coherent text structure while writers with cognitive-language impairment demonstrate problems with global text coherence and the episodic structure of texts. Results of the generic structure analysis did not support the hypothesis. However, the semantic Move analysis revealed how diminished linguistic resources, most evident in the letters written by the subjects with aphasia, impacted upon the semantic diversity of the text, as well as the interpersonal function of the personal letter. Variable performance as a feature pathology and normality is highlighted and clinical implications discussed.
这项定性研究调查了10名中风后失语症患者和10名因创伤性脑损伤导致认知语言障碍的患者所写的私人信件形式的书面话语,并将他们的表现与15名无脑部损伤的写作者进行了比较。私人信件具有提供信息和维持社会关系的双重功能。运用系统功能语言学框架进行调查,从信件的双重功能以及语言的两个不同层次——语类结构和语义组织方面对信件进行了分析。少量研究表明,在失语症患者和认知语言障碍患者的口语中发现的不同语言层次(即宏观和微观语言能力)之间的分离在书面话语中也有体现。失语症写作者在很大程度上能保持连贯的文本结构,而有认知语言障碍的写作者在整体文本连贯性和文本的情节结构方面存在问题。语类结构分析的结果不支持该假设。然而,语义推进分析揭示了语言资源的减少(在失语症患者所写的信件中最为明显)如何影响文本的语义多样性以及私人信件的人际功能。强调了作为特征性病理和正常表现的可变表现,并讨论了临床意义。