Mascareñas A, Salinas J, Tasset-Tisseau A, Mascareñas C, Khan M M
Mexican Vaccinology Association, Monterrey, Mexico.
Public Health. 2005 Jun;119(6):542-9. doi: 10.1016/j.puhe.2004.08.020.
The World Health Organization recommends that all children aged less than 5 years should be vaccinated against polio through intensive immunization programmes as well as routine immunization. A national immunization week (NIW) was held in February 2002 in the Monterrey district of Mexico. A prospective micro-costing study was conducted to measure the total cost to the state of the NIW, the cost profile, and the ratio of cost per immunization contact to cost per dose of oral polio vaccine (OPV), and to compare OPV and inactive polio vaccine (IPV) in economic terms. Two scenarios were used as the basis for calculation. The cost of volunteers was excluded from the "lower-cost scenario" and included in the "upper-cost scenario". The total cost of the NIW was USD 100,454 for the lower-cost scenario and USD 156,614 for the upper-cost scenario. The major part of the costs was personnel costs (67.30 and 77.53% of the total costs in the lower- and upper-cost scenario, respectively). The ratio of cost per immunization contact to cost per dose of OPV was 6.45 for the lower-cost scenario and 10.05 for the upper-cost scenario. Changing from the current OPV-based intensive and routine schedule to a sequential IPV-OPV routine schedule would save USD 14.52 per vaccinated child, and changing to a full IPV routine schedule would save USD 9.41 per vaccinated child.
世界卫生组织建议,所有5岁以下儿童都应通过强化免疫计划以及常规免疫接种脊髓灰质炎疫苗。2002年2月,墨西哥蒙特雷地区举办了全国免疫周活动。开展了一项前瞻性微观成本核算研究,以衡量全国免疫周活动对该州造成的总成本、成本构成,以及每次免疫接种接触成本与每剂口服脊髓灰质炎疫苗(OPV)成本的比率,并从经济角度比较OPV和灭活脊髓灰质炎疫苗(IPV)。计算以两种方案为基础。“低成本方案”中未计入志愿者成本,“高成本方案”中则计入了志愿者成本。低成本方案下全国免疫周活动的总成本为100,454美元,高成本方案下为156,614美元。成本的主要部分是人员成本(分别占低成本方案和高成本方案总成本的67.30%和77.53%)。低成本方案下每次免疫接种接触成本与每剂OPV成本的比率为6.45,高成本方案下为10.05。从目前基于OPV的强化和常规免疫程序改为IPV-OPV序贯常规免疫程序,每名接种儿童可节省14.52美元;改为全程IPV常规免疫程序,每名接种儿童可节省9.41美元。