Yoshioka Toshimasa, Suganuma Taiyo, Tang Ann C, Matsushita Susumu, Manno Sumie, Kozu Tadahiko
Tokyo Women's Medical University School of Medicine, Department of Medical Education, Tokyo 162-8666, Japan.
Teach Learn Med. 2005 Spring;17(2):136-41. doi: 10.1207/s15328015tlm1702_7.
Adaptation to problem-based learning (PBL) is a difficult process for high school graduates who are not used to self-directed learning, especially in the freshmen year of medical school. The difficulty includes finding problems from a given case.
Evaluate the effect of an intervention to facilitate case-based problem finding among medical school freshmen undergoing a PBL tutorial.
Medical school freshmen in 2000 (nonintervened group) and 2001 (intervened group) participated in the study. The intervened group received the modified problem-based program by (a) having briefings on the importance of problem finding, (b) encouragement by the tutors in problem finding, and (c) reinforcement using a self-assessment sheet. At the end of the year, the ability of students to extract problems from a short case was evaluated and compared with the nonintervened students.
The intervened group extracted a significantly greater number of problems than the nonintervened group. When extracted problems were categorized, the intervened group was able to generate more questions in a greater number of specified categories.
Interventions to foster problem finding significantly facilitated acquisition of problem extraction skills among young medical students.
对于不习惯自主学习的高中毕业生而言,适应基于问题的学习(PBL)是一个艰难的过程,尤其是在医学院的一年级。困难包括从给定案例中找出问题。
评估一项干预措施对医学院接受PBL辅导的新生基于案例的问题发现能力的影响。
2000年入学的医学院新生(未干预组)和2001年入学的新生(干预组)参与了该研究。干预组接受了改进后的基于问题的课程,具体方式为:(a)介绍问题发现的重要性,(b)导师在问题发现方面给予鼓励,(c)使用自我评估表进行强化。在学年末,评估学生从简短案例中提取问题的能力,并与未干预的学生进行比较。
干预组提取的问题数量显著多于未干预组。对提取的问题进行分类时,干预组能够在更多指定类别中提出更多问题。
培养问题发现能力的干预措施显著促进了年轻医学生问题提取技能的获得。