Gatesy J, Yelon D, DeSalle R, Vrba E S
Department of Geology and Geophysics, Yale University, New York, New York.
Mol Biol Evol. 1992 May;9(3):433-46. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.molbev.a040734.
Portions of the 12S and 16S mitochondrial ribosomal genes for 16 species representing nine tribes in the mammal family Bovidae were compared with six previously published orthologous sequences. Phylogenetic analysis of variable nucleotide positions under different constraints and weighting schemes revealed no robust groupings among tribes. Consensus trees support previous hypotheses of monophyly for four clades, including the traditional subfamily Bovinae. However, the basal diversification of bovid tribes, which was largely unresolved by morphological, immunodiffusion, allozyme, and protein sequence data, remains unresolved with the addition of DNA sequence data. The intractability of this systematic problem is consistent with a rapid radiation of the major bovid groups. Several analyses of our data show that monophyly of the Bovidae, which was weakly supported by previous morphological and molecular work, is questionable.
对牛科哺乳动物九个部落的16个物种的12S和16S线粒体核糖体基因部分与六个先前发表的直系同源序列进行了比较。在不同的约束和加权方案下对可变核苷酸位置进行系统发育分析,结果显示各部落之间没有稳健的分组。一致树支持了包括传统牛亚科在内的四个进化枝单系性的先前假设。然而,牛科部落的基部多样化在很大程度上未被形态学、免疫扩散、等位酶和蛋白质序列数据解决,随着DNA序列数据的加入,这一问题仍然未得到解决。这个系统发育问题的棘手性与主要牛科类群的快速辐射是一致的。对我们数据的几项分析表明,牛科的单系性在先前的形态学和分子研究中得到的支持较弱,这一点值得怀疑。