Ring David, Kocher Mininder, Koris Mark, Thornhill Thomas S
Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005 May;87(5):1075-9. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.D.02449.
Instability is a recognized complication associated with unlinked total elbow implants. The best form of treatment of this problem is uncertain as very little has been written about it.
Twelve patients underwent operative treatment of instability at the site of a capitellocondylar unlinked total elbow replacement, and the results were reviewed retrospectively. The study group included ten women and two men with an average age of fifty-eight years. Ten patients had rheumatoid arthritis. Three elbows underwent conversion to a semi-constrained hinged prosthesis. In the other nine elbows, an attempt was made to continue with an unlinked prosthesis: three had reconstruction of one or both collateral ligaments, four had component revision, and two had both ligament reconstruction and component revision.
After an average duration of follow-up of six years (range, two to fifteen years) only three patients had retained a functioning unlinked prosthesis. Of the remaining nine patients, three had had a conversion to a semi-constrained arthroplasty at the time of the index procedure, four had had a conversion to a semi-constrained prosthesis at the time of a salvage procedure, one had had a resection arthroplasty, and one had a painfully dislocated elbow and had declined revision. Thus, seven elbows eventually underwent conversion to a semi-constrained prosthesis; these conversion procedures were technically difficult, with perforation of the humerus occurring in six patients and perforation of the ulna occurring in four. After all procedures, the average elbow flexion was 132 degrees and the average flexion contracture was 25 degrees. According to the Mayo Elbow Performance Index, there were four excellent results, three good results, three fair results, and one poor result.
Revision of an unlinked total elbow prosthesis to a linked total elbow prosthesis is difficult, but it restores elbow function. Although the present series documents the unpredictability of attempts to salvage an unstable unlinked prosthesis, it seems reasonable to attempt at least one soft-tissue procedure before converting to a linked prosthesis.
不稳定是与非铰链式全肘关节假体相关的一种公认并发症。由于对此问题的相关报道极少,所以该问题的最佳治疗方式尚不确定。
对12例在髁间非铰链式全肘关节置换部位出现不稳定情况而接受手术治疗的患者进行回顾性结果分析。研究组包括10名女性和2名男性,平均年龄58岁。10例患者患有类风湿关节炎。3例肘关节转换为半限制型铰链式假体。在另外9例肘关节中,尝试继续使用非铰链式假体:3例对一条或两条侧副韧带进行了重建,4例进行了假体翻修,2例同时进行了韧带重建和假体翻修。
平均随访6年(范围2至15年)后,仅3例患者保留了功能良好的非铰链式假体。其余9例患者中,3例在初次手术时转换为半限制型关节成形术,4例在补救手术时转换为半限制型假体,1例进行了切除成形术,1例肘关节疼痛性脱位且拒绝翻修。因此,最终7例肘关节转换为半限制型假体;这些转换手术技术难度大,6例患者出现肱骨穿孔,4例患者出现尺骨穿孔。所有手术完成后,肘关节平均屈曲度为132度,平均屈曲挛缩为25度。根据梅奥肘关节功能指数,结果为优4例,良3例,中3例,差1例。
将非铰链式全肘关节假体翻修为铰链式全肘关节假体难度较大,但能恢复肘关节功能。尽管本系列研究记录了挽救不稳定非铰链式假体尝试的不可预测性,但在转换为铰链式假体之前至少尝试一次软组织手术似乎是合理的。