Punamäki Raija-Leena, Komproe Ivan, Qouta Samir, El-Masri Mustafa, de Jong J T V M
Department of Psychology, University of Tampere, 33014 Tampere, Finland.
Child Abuse Negl. 2005 Apr;29(4):351-73. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2004.10.011. Epub 2005 Apr 26.
To show that exposure to childhood maltreatment deteriorates, whereas exposure to adulthood military violence mobilizes social support; second, to show that associations between traumatic events and mental health problems are mediated through social support and, subsequently, adulthood military violence is associated with low level and childhood maltreatment with high level of mental health symptoms; third, to explore whether the moderating (protecting) effect of sufficient and satisfactory social support would differ among victims of childhood maltreatment and adulthood military violence.
The participants were a random-sample of Palestinian men and women (n=585) of 16-60 years of age. Exposure to military violence in adulthood was assessed by the Harvard Trauma Questionnaire (HTQ_I), and to childhood maltreatment by a 13-item questionnaire developed for the study. A Social Network Schedule was applied to assess the function, source, and satisfaction with social support, and the Revised SCL90-R Symptoms Checklist to assess mental health symptoms.
Findings supported our hypothesis that exposure to childhood maltreatment was associated with low levels of social support, whereas exposure to adulthood military violence was associated with high levels of social support. Contrary to our second hypothesis, both childhood maltreatment and adulthood military violence were associated with high levels of mental health symptoms. Finally, high level and satisfactory social support moderated the association between exposure to military violence in adulthood and mental health symptoms, but not between childhood maltreatment and mental health symptoms.
The findings emphasize that the nature of trauma, that is, whether familial or political, determines the availability of protective resources versus vulnerability, which should be considered when tailoring interventions to trauma victims.
一是表明童年期受虐待会导致社会支持水平下降,而成年期经历军事暴力则会调动社会支持;二是表明创伤事件与心理健康问题之间的关联是通过社会支持来介导的,随后,成年期军事暴力与低水平心理健康症状相关,童年期受虐待与高水平心理健康症状相关;三是探讨充足且令人满意的社会支持的调节(保护)作用在童年期受虐待的受害者和成年期经历军事暴力的受害者之间是否存在差异。
参与者是16至60岁的巴勒斯坦男女随机样本(n = 585)。成年期军事暴力暴露通过哈佛创伤问卷(HTQ_I)进行评估,童年期受虐待情况通过为本研究编制的一份包含13个条目的问卷进行评估。应用社会网络时间表来评估社会支持的功能、来源和满意度,并使用修订版SCL90 - R症状清单来评估心理健康症状。
研究结果支持了我们的假设,即童年期受虐待与低水平社会支持相关,而成年期经历军事暴力与高水平社会支持相关。与我们的第二个假设相反,童年期受虐待和成年期军事暴力都与高水平心理健康症状相关。最后,高水平且令人满意的社会支持调节了成年期军事暴力暴露与心理健康症状之间的关联,但未调节童年期受虐待与心理健康症状之间的关联。
研究结果强调,创伤的性质,即无论是家庭性的还是政治性的,决定了保护性资源的可获得性与易损性,在为创伤受害者量身定制干预措施时应考虑这一点。