Ueguchi Takashi, Johkoh Takeshi, Tomiyama Noriyuki, Honda Osamu, Mihara Naoki, Hamada Seiki, Murai Sachiko, Ogata Yuji, Matsumoto Mitsuhiro, Nakamura Hironobu
Department of Radiology, Osaka University Hospital, Osaka 565-0871, Japan.
Radiat Med. 2005 May;23(3):170-4.
To compare observer performance in the detection of subtle interstitial abnormalities on 3,520 x 3,520 (4K) matrix and 1,760 x 1,760 (2K) matrix full-size digital storage phosphor (DSP) chest radiographs.
Thirty-five 4K DSP chest radiographs with subtle interstitial abnormalities (n=27) or normal lungs (n=8) were processed with a half-band low-pass filter to produce 2K DSP radiographs. Although the actual matrix size of the 2K DSP radiographs remained 4K, the effective matrix size was reduced to 2K. Four chest radiologists independently evaluated full-sized hard-copy of the 4K and 2K DSP radiographs, and scored the presence of interstitial abnormalities for both right and left lungs on a five-point confidence scale. With findings on high-resolution computed tomography as the reference standard, observer performance was evaluated using multireader-multicase receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis.
The average area under the ROC curve (Az) values for 4K and 2K DSP radiographs were 0.791+/-0.055 and 0.804+/-0.050, respectively. Both individual and averaged Az values showed no statistically significant differences (p>0.05) between 4K and 2K DSP radiographs.
Observer performance in the detection of subtle interstitial abnormalities on 4K full-size DSP chest radiographs was equivalent to that on 2K full-size DSP chest radiographs.
比较在3520×3520(4K)矩阵和1760×1760(2K)矩阵的全尺寸数字存储磷光体(DSP)胸部X线片上,观察者对细微间质异常的检测表现。
对35张有细微间质异常(n = 27)或肺部正常(n = 8)的4K DSP胸部X线片使用半带低通滤波器进行处理,以生成2K DSP X线片。尽管2K DSP X线片的实际矩阵大小仍为4K,但有效矩阵大小减小到了2K。四位胸部放射科医生独立评估4K和2K DSP X线片的全尺寸硬拷贝,并以五点置信度量表对左右肺间质异常的存在情况进行评分。以高分辨率计算机断层扫描的结果作为参考标准,使用多读者多病例接受者操作特征(ROC)分析来评估观察者的表现。
4K和2K DSP X线片的ROC曲线下平均面积(Az)值分别为0.791±0.055和0.804±0.050。4K和2K DSP X线片的个体和平均Az值均无统计学显著差异(p>0.05)。
在4K全尺寸DSP胸部X线片上检测细微间质异常时,观察者的表现与在2K全尺寸DSP胸部X线片上相当。