Tung Celestine S, Middleman Amy B
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA.
J Adolesc Health. 2005 Jul;37(1):61-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2004.07.019.
To examine the effect of different school-level factors on the percent return of consent or refusal forms, the percent student participation/enrollment rate, and the percent completion rate of all 3 immunizations in the vaccination series in a school-based hepatitis B immunization initiative.
The Houston Hepatitis B Immunization Initiative (HBII) was conducted from 1998 through 2001 to provide free hepatitis B immunizations to elementary school students in low socioeconomic areas. At the end of each academic school year, the nurse from each school participating in the initiative was asked to complete a survey evaluating the different strategies utilized in each school to aid in the program's success. The effect of different organizational methods on rate of return of consent/refusal forms, participation rates, and immunization completion rates from the program year 1999-2000 was determined using frequencies, Mann-Whitney analyses, Kruskal-Wallis analyses, and Spearman's correlations.
An increase in percent return of signed consent/refusal forms was more likely when teachers helped in publicity/promotion (p = .012) and educational packet distribution (p = .041). Additionally, when teachers assumed responsibility for collecting the forms, the percent return of signed consent/refusal forms (p = .018) and the percent of students receiving all 3 vaccines in the series through HBII (p = .030) were more likely to increase. An increase in signed consent/refusal forms returned was also associated with increased rates of student participation in the program for each school. In schools where students helped specifically with educational packet distribution (p = .039), the percent of students receiving at least 1 vaccine dose from the program was more likely to be higher.
The involvement of teachers in vaccination programs is very important for program success, especially in the enrollment and return of consent/refusal form phases of immunization initiatives. Student involvement may empower the students and encourage other students to participate in the program. Future school-based immunization initiatives can utilize these data to incorporate the most effective school-level factors into their programs to maximize the number of students immunized.
在一项基于学校的乙肝免疫接种倡议中,研究不同学校层面因素对同意书或拒绝书的返还率、学生参与率/入学率以及疫苗接种系列中所有3种免疫接种的完成率的影响。
休斯顿乙肝免疫接种倡议(HBII)于1998年至2001年开展,为社会经济地位较低地区的小学生提供免费乙肝免疫接种。在每个学年结束时,要求参与该倡议的每所学校的护士完成一项调查,评估每所学校为帮助该项目取得成功而采用的不同策略。使用频率分析、曼-惠特尼分析、克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯分析和斯皮尔曼相关性分析,确定了1999 - 2000学年不同组织方法对同意/拒绝书返还率、参与率和免疫接种完成率的影响。
当教师协助进行宣传/推广(p = 0.012)和发放教育资料包(p = 0.041)时,签署的同意/拒绝书的返还率更有可能提高。此外,当教师负责收集这些表格时,签署的同意/拒绝书的返还率(p = 0.018)以及通过HBII接受该系列所有3种疫苗的学生比例(p = 0.030)更有可能提高。签署的同意/拒绝书返还率的提高也与每所学校学生参与该项目的比率增加有关。在学生专门协助发放教育资料包的学校(p = 0.039),从该项目中接受至少一剂疫苗的学生比例更有可能更高。
教师参与疫苗接种项目对项目成功非常重要,尤其是在免疫接种倡议的登记和同意/拒绝书返还阶段。学生的参与可能会增强学生的能力,并鼓励其他学生参与该项目。未来基于学校的免疫接种倡议可以利用这些数据,将最有效的学校层面因素纳入其项目中,以最大限度地提高接种疫苗学生的数量。