Kenna George A, Wood Mark D
Community Health, Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies, Brown University, Providence, RI 02908, USA.
J Am Dent Assoc. 2005 Jul;136(7):1023-32. doi: 10.14219/jada.archive.2005.0297.
Primarily on the basis of qualitative data, use of alcohol and illicit drugs has been speculated to be higher among dentists. The authors conducted a study to assess self-reported substance use by dentists and compare these data with those regarding physicians and the general population (GP).
A total of 113 dentists (65.3 percent) and 104 physicians (63.4 percent) from a northeastern state responded to a seven-page self-report survey during the summer of 2002. The survey assessed health care professionals' alcohol, cigarette and drug use; consequences of use; disciplinary occurrences and treatment; and professional and social influences.
Although about twice as many physicians as dentists reported heavy alcohol use, a greater number of dentists reported heavy episodic alcohol use over the past year and past month, as well as having more alcohol-use problems than physicians. Roughly twice as many physicians and three times the GP reported using anxiolytics than did dentists. More dentists than physicians reported past-year, but not past-month, minor opiate use. While more dentists reported being in social situations in which they were offered alcohol, more physicians reported being offered alcohol by pharmaceutical companies at various functions.
Contrary to previous speculation, there is little evidence from the prevalence data the authors analyzed for this report to suggest that dentists are at a greater risk of developing alcohol- or other drug-use problems than is the GP.
While the findings of this study do not suggest that substance use is more prevalent among dentists, educational institutions and state organizations still must be vigilant in educating, monitoring and encouraging dentists to voluntarily receive treatment.
主要基于定性数据推测,牙医群体中酒精和非法药物的使用比例可能更高。作者开展了一项研究,以评估牙医自我报告的物质使用情况,并将这些数据与医生及普通人群的数据进行比较。
2002年夏季,来自美国东北部一个州的113名牙医(65.3%)和104名医生(63.4%)回应了一份长达7页的自我报告调查问卷。该调查评估了医疗保健专业人员的酒精、香烟和药物使用情况;使用的后果;纪律事件及治疗情况;以及职业和社会影响。
虽然报告大量饮酒的医生人数约为牙医的两倍,但在过去一年和过去一个月中,报告有大量偶发性饮酒情况的牙医人数更多,且牙医存在的酒精使用问题比医生更多。报告使用抗焦虑药的医生人数约为牙医的两倍,普通人群报告使用抗焦虑药的人数则是牙医的三倍。报告过去一年使用过少量阿片类药物的牙医人数多于医生,但过去一个月的情况并非如此。虽然更多牙医报告在社交场合有人向他们提供酒精,但更多医生报告在各种活动中制药公司向他们提供酒精。
与之前的推测相反,作者为这份报告分析的患病率数据几乎没有证据表明,牙医比普通人群有更高的风险出现酒精或其他药物使用问题。
虽然本研究结果并未表明物质使用在牙医中更为普遍,但教育机构和州组织仍必须保持警惕,对牙医进行教育、监测,并鼓励他们自愿接受治疗。