Hamunen Katri, Kontinen Vesa
Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, Helsinki University Central Hospital, Helsinki, Finland.
Pain. 2005 Sep;117(1-2):40-50. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2005.05.012.
In this systematic review effectiveness of analgesics for pain after tonsillectomy in children was evaluated and trial methodology of the included studies explored. Databases were searched for randomised, controlled studies on systemic paracetamol, NSAIDs and opioids. Eighty-four studies were evaluated for inclusion. Thirty-six studies were included and 48 excluded. Only in two studies investigated analgesics were given postoperatively for pain. All other studies investigated prophylactic administration of analgesics. Only five studies were truly placebo controlled. Trial methodology of the included studies varied greatly in respect to analgesics and doses used, duration of follow-up periods, methods of pain measurement, rescue analgesics and criteria for administrating rescue analgesia used. Sensitivity of studies was often unclear. Only 16 out of 36 studies were considered to be sensitive. Because of highly variable methodology and lack of sensitivity only limited conclusions on clinical efficacy of analgesics investigated can be drawn. No analgesic in single prophylactic dose provided analgesia for day of operation. Further studies are needed to find the optimal analgesic(s) for pain after tonsillectomy in children.
在这项系统评价中,评估了镇痛药对儿童扁桃体切除术后疼痛的有效性,并探讨了纳入研究的试验方法。检索数据库以查找关于全身性对乙酰氨基酚、非甾体抗炎药和阿片类药物的随机对照研究。对84项研究进行了纳入评估。纳入36项研究,排除48项。仅在两项研究中,研究的镇痛药是术后用于止痛的。所有其他研究均调查了镇痛药的预防性给药。只有五项研究是真正的安慰剂对照。纳入研究的试验方法在所用镇痛药和剂量、随访期持续时间、疼痛测量方法、解救镇痛药以及使用解救镇痛的标准方面差异很大。研究的敏感性往往不明确。36项研究中只有16项被认为是敏感的。由于方法高度可变且缺乏敏感性,因此对于所研究镇痛药的临床疗效只能得出有限的结论。没有单一预防性剂量的镇痛药能在手术当天提供镇痛效果。需要进一步研究以找到儿童扁桃体切除术后疼痛的最佳镇痛药。