Eze N, Lo S, Bray D, Toma A G
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, St George's Hospital Medical School, University of London, London, UK.
Clin Otolaryngol. 2005 Jun;30(3):230-3; discussion 233. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2273.2005.00982.x.
To determine the accuracy of assessment of common ENT emergency radiological investigations using mobile phone digital images.
Prospective case controlled series.
Tertiary referral otolaryngology centre.
Fourteen randomly selected patients who underwent emergency ENT radiological investigations over a 1-month period.
The accuracy and confidence of six ENT consultants and five specialist registrars in making diagnoses based on a brief history and assessment of CT scans and X-ray images taken from and transmitted via a mobile phone, compared with examination of the same films on a conventional X-ray box.
With 14 films, a total of 154 cases were assessed by the 11 subjects. All doctors made the correct diagnosis for every case examined. Overall, the relative confidence of diagnosis was ranked highly for both image media, although the overall confidence of diagnosis using the X-ray box was significantly greater than the mobile phone (95% CI upper bound = 1.6 lower bound = 0.9; paired t-test P < 0.0001). The seniority of the clinician did not predict a difference in the confidence of diagnosis (P = 0.3). There is no statistical relationship between confidence of diagnosis of the original films and degradation of film quality on the mobile phone (P = 0.7).
The accuracy and confidence of diagnosis of common ENT emergency radiological investigations using mobile phone digital images seem compatible with X-ray box. Financially it is a much cheaper than conventional telemedicine technology. It may be used to augment information sent to non-resident specialists in the management of emergency ENT cases.
使用手机数字图像确定常见耳鼻喉科急诊放射学检查评估的准确性。
前瞻性病例对照系列研究。
三级转诊耳鼻喉科中心。
在1个月内随机选取的14例接受耳鼻喉科急诊放射学检查的患者。
6名耳鼻喉科顾问和5名专科住院医师根据简要病史以及对通过手机拍摄和传输的CT扫描和X线图像进行评估来做出诊断的准确性和信心,与在传统X线阅片箱上检查相同胶片进行比较。
11名受试者对14张胶片共评估了154例病例。所有医生对所检查的每个病例都做出了正确诊断。总体而言,两种图像介质的诊断相对信心度都很高,尽管使用X线阅片箱的总体诊断信心度明显高于手机(95%可信区间上限 = 1.6,下限 = 0.9;配对t检验P < 0.0001)。临床医生的资历并不能预测诊断信心的差异(P = 0.3)。原始胶片的诊断信心与手机上胶片质量的下降之间没有统计学关系(P = 0.7)。
使用手机数字图像对常见耳鼻喉科急诊放射学检查进行诊断的准确性和信心似乎与X线阅片箱相当。从经济角度看,它比传统远程医疗技术便宜得多。它可用于在耳鼻喉科急诊病例管理中增加发送给非驻地专家的信息。