Dunlop Rebecca, Laming Peter
School of Biology and Biochemistry, Medical Biology Centre, Queen's University of Belfast, Belfast, Northern Ireland.
J Pain. 2005 Sep;6(9):561-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2005.02.010.
Nociceptive responses to a repetitive pin-prod stimulus in goldfish and trout were assessed. Single unit recordings were taken from the spinal cord, cerebellum, tectum, and telencephalon. Neuronal responses were elicited in all these regions of the central nervous system in both species of fish during brush (mechanoceptive) and pin-prod (nociceptive) stimuli. In addition, in trout, a heated prod stimulus was used. Mechanoreceptive and nociceptive neuronal responses to various stimuli were elicited in all regions, and responses were detected as far as the telencephalon in both species. In goldfish, a noxious stimulus produced greater neuronal activity than a mechanoreceptive stimulus. This was not found in trout. The accurate setting of timed prods allowed the latency of the response to be calculated in all regions. From these data, conduction velocities suggested that A delta and C fibers were activated; both fiber groups previously have been shown to be involved in nociception in fish. This study has shown that there is neuronal activity in all brain areas including the telencephalon, suggesting a nociceptive pathway from the periphery to the higher central nervous system of fish.
This study presents novel data on telencephalic activity in fish after noxious stimulation and demonstrates the potential for pain perception in lower vertebrates. Not only is this of an evolutionary significance, but it also adds to the controversial argument about whether fish perceive pain.
评估了金鱼和鳟鱼对重复性针刺刺激的伤害性反应。从脊髓、小脑、视顶盖和端脑进行了单单位记录。在两种鱼类的刷擦(机械感受性)和针刺(伤害性)刺激过程中,中枢神经系统的所有这些区域均引发了神经元反应。此外,在鳟鱼中还使用了热针刺激。所有区域均引发了对各种刺激的机械感受性和伤害性神经元反应,并且在两种鱼类中均检测到了直至端脑的反应。在金鱼中,有害刺激比机械感受性刺激产生了更大的神经元活动。在鳟鱼中未发现这种情况。定时针刺的精确设置使得能够计算所有区域反应的潜伏期。根据这些数据,传导速度表明Aδ纤维和C纤维被激活;先前已证明这两种纤维组都参与鱼类的伤害感受。这项研究表明,包括端脑在内的所有脑区都存在神经元活动,这表明从外周到鱼类高级中枢神经系统存在一条伤害感受通路。
这项研究提供了关于鱼类有害刺激后端脑活动的新数据,并证明了低等脊椎动物具有疼痛感知的潜力。这不仅具有进化意义,而且也为关于鱼类是否感知疼痛的争议性论点增添了内容。