Damasceno Alfredo, Delicio Adriane M, Mazo Daniel F C, Zullo João F D, Scherer Patricia, Ng Ronny T Y, Damasceno Benito P
Department of Neurology, Medical School, State University of Campinas, Campinas, SP, Brazil.
Arq Neuropsiquiatr. 2005 Sep;63(3A):577-82. doi: 10.1590/s0004-282x2005000400004. Epub 2005 Sep 9.
Data on the prevalence of primitive reflexes (PR) in adulthood, their pathological significance and relationship to age and cognition are controversial.
To study the relationship between PR and cognition in 30 patients with probable Alzheimer's disease (AD) and 154 control subjects.
Diagnosis of probable AD was based on DSM-IV, NINCDS-ADRDA, and CAMDEX criteria. Primitive reflexes were quantified from zero (absent) to 1 (mild) or 2 (markedly present). The Cognitive Abilities Screening Instrument-Short Form (CASI-S) was used to evaluate registration, temporal orientation, verbal fluency and recall. A drawing test was added.
Most frequent PR among demented and controls were suck (77% and 62%, respectively) and snout (60% and 27%), followed by glabellar (30% and 19%), paratonia (37% and 5%), and palmomental (23% and 5%). None of controls had more than three PR. Frequency of PR tended to increase with age and cognitive deterioration. Grasp and Babinski responses were found only in dementia patients. Primitive reflexes were not correlated with each other, except snout with suck, and snout with glabellar reflex.
The finding of grasp and Babinski sign, or the presence of more than three primitive signs, particularly the combination of paratonia, snout, suck, and palmomental reflexes strongly suggests brain dysfunction, especially when these signs are marked and accompanied by deficits in orientation, recall, verbal fluency, and constructional praxis.
关于成人原始反射(PR)的患病率、其病理意义以及与年龄和认知的关系的数据存在争议。
研究30例疑似阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者和154例对照者中PR与认知的关系。
疑似AD的诊断基于DSM-IV、NINCDS-ADRDA和CAMDEX标准。原始反射从零(无)到1(轻度)或2(明显存在)进行量化。使用认知能力筛查工具简表(CASI-S)评估登记、时间定向、语言流畅性和回忆。增加了一项绘图测试。
痴呆患者和对照者中最常见的PR是吸吮反射(分别为77%和62%)和噘嘴反射(60%和27%),其次是眉间反射(30%和19%)、 gegenhalten反射(37%和5%)和掌颏反射(23%和5%)。没有对照者的PR超过三种。PR的频率倾向于随年龄和认知功能恶化而增加。抓握反射和巴宾斯基反射仅在痴呆患者中发现。除了噘嘴反射与吸吮反射以及噘嘴反射与眉间反射相关外,原始反射之间没有相互关联。
发现抓握反射和巴宾斯基征,或存在超过三种原始体征,特别是gegenhalten反射、噘嘴反射、吸吮反射和掌颏反射的组合,强烈提示脑功能障碍,尤其是当这些体征明显并伴有定向、回忆、语言流畅性和结构性运用障碍时。