Schonfeld Amy M, Mattson Sarah N, Riley Edward P
Center for Behavioral Teratology, San Diego State University, San Diego, California, USA.
J Stud Alcohol. 2005 Jul;66(4):545-54. doi: 10.15288/jsa.2005.66.545.
Prenatal exposure to alcohol is associated with cognitive, behavioral and social deficits, including delinquency. Although delinquent populations and those with intellectual and behavioral deficits exhibit impaired moral judgment and reasoning, this area remains unexplored in alcohol-exposed individuals.
Moral maturity and delinquency were evaluated in 27 participants with prenatal alcohol exposure (ALC group) and 29 nonexposed controls (CON group) matched on age (range: 10-18), gender, handedness, socioeconomic status and ethnicity. Moral maturity was evaluated using the Sociomoral Reflection Measure-Short Form, and delinquency was evaluated with the Conduct Disorder (CD) Questionnaire. Additional measures included social desirability and inhibition.
The ALC group performed at a lower level of moral maturity than the CON group. Whereas Verbal IQ primarily predicted this difference, a deficit on the moral value judgment having to do with relationships with others was specific to prenatal alcohol exposure. Furthermore, delinquency was higher in the ALC group, and specific sociomoral values were predictive of delinquent behavior. Finally, half of the children and adolescents with a history of prenatal alcohol exposure but without fetal alcohol syndrome had probable CD.
The results of this study indicate that interventions aimed at reducing delinquency in those with prenatal alcohol exposure are necessary, and targeting moral judgment for this purpose may be beneficial.
产前暴露于酒精与认知、行为和社会缺陷有关,包括犯罪行为。尽管犯罪人群以及那些有智力和行为缺陷的人表现出道德判断和推理能力受损,但在产前酒精暴露个体中,这一领域仍未得到探索。
对27名产前酒精暴露参与者(酒精组)和29名未暴露的对照组(对照组)进行道德成熟度和犯罪行为评估,两组在年龄(范围:10 - 18岁)、性别、利手、社会经济地位和种族方面相匹配。使用社会道德反思测量简表评估道德成熟度,使用品行障碍(CD)问卷评估犯罪行为。其他测量包括社会期望和抑制能力。
酒精组的道德成熟度水平低于对照组。虽然言语智商是造成这种差异的主要预测因素,但与他人关系方面的道德价值判断缺陷是产前酒精暴露所特有的。此外,酒精组的犯罪行为发生率更高,特定的社会道德价值观可预测犯罪行为。最后,一半有产前酒精暴露史但无胎儿酒精综合征的儿童和青少年可能患有品行障碍。
本研究结果表明,有必要采取干预措施来减少产前酒精暴露个体的犯罪行为,为此针对道德判断进行干预可能会有所帮助。