Chanut Florence, Brown Thomas G, Dongier Maurice
Addiction Research Program, Douglas Hospital, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec.
Can J Psychiatry. 2005 Aug;50(9):548-54. doi: 10.1177/070674370505000908.
Our objectives were as follows: (1) to survey the literature on motivational interviewing (MI), "a client-centered yet directive method for enhancing intrinsic motivation to change by exploring and resolving client ambivalence" and a well-established method of brief intervention, especially in the field of addictions treatment; (2) to review hypotheses about its mode of action; and (3) to discuss its possible impact on clinical psychiatry, in particular, on teaching communications skills.
Literature reviews and metaanalyses of numerous clinical trials of MI for addictions treatment have already been published and are briefly summarized. So far, no literature survey exists for MI applied to psychiatric patients. This review is limited to a synthesis of the articles relevant to psychiatry and to comments based on our team's experiences with MI.
There is no evidence that MI achieves better results than other established techniques for treating addictions; it may simply work faster. The explanation for the method's rapid effectiveness remains speculative. Outcomes concerning the application of MI to psychiatric patients, although preliminary, are promising. Methods of assessing the integrity of MI treatment are more developed than in most psychotherapies, which permits the learning progress of trainees to be measured.
MI offers a complement to usual psychiatric procedures. It may be worthwhile to teach it, not only for addictions but also for other broad treatment issues, such as enhancing patients' medication compliance and professionals' communication skills. Questions remain concerning MI's feasibility in psychiatry settings.
我们的目标如下:(1)调查关于动机性访谈(MI)的文献,“一种以客户为中心但具有指导性的方法,通过探索和解决客户的矛盾心理来增强内在改变动机”,这是一种成熟的简短干预方法,尤其在成瘾治疗领域;(2)回顾关于其作用方式的假设;(3)讨论其对临床精神病学可能产生的影响,特别是对教学沟通技巧的影响。
已经发表了许多关于MI用于成瘾治疗的临床试验的文献综述和荟萃分析,并进行了简要总结。到目前为止,尚无针对应用于精神病患者的MI的文献调查。本综述仅限于综合与精神病学相关的文章,并基于我们团队对MI的经验发表评论。
没有证据表明MI在治疗成瘾方面比其他既定技术取得更好的效果;它可能只是起效更快。该方法快速起效的原因仍属推测。关于MI应用于精神病患者的结果,尽管尚属初步,但很有前景。评估MI治疗完整性的方法比大多数心理治疗方法更为完善,这使得能够衡量受训人员的学习进展。
MI为常规精神病学程序提供了一种补充。教授MI可能是值得的,不仅适用于成瘾治疗,也适用于其他广泛的治疗问题,如提高患者的药物依从性和专业人员的沟通技巧。关于MI在精神病学环境中的可行性仍存在问题。