Martínez-González Miguel Angel, López-Fontana Constanza, Varo José Javier, Sánchez-Villegas Almudena, Martinez J Alfredo
Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Navarra, Irunlarrea s/n, E-31080 Pamplona, Spain.
Public Health Nutr. 2005 Oct;8(7):920-7. doi: 10.1079/phn2005745.
The objective of this analysis was to test the validity of the estimates of energy expenditure and sedentary lifestyle obtained through a self-administered questionnaire of physical activity for Spanish-speaking people adapted from US questionnaires (Nurses' Health Study and Health Professionals' Follow-up Study) using a triaxial accelerometer (RT3 Triaxial Research Tracker) as the reference.
Validation study, calculating the non-parametric correlation coefficients between the level of physical activity and sedentary lifestyle collected by the self-administered questionnaire and the triaxial accelerometer measurements. Percentage of misclassification and kappa coefficients were also calculated.
The study population consisted of a sample of 40 obese women who were participants of the SUN (Seguimiento Universidad de Navarra) project (a prospective cohort study among Spanish university alumni). They were selected because of their peculiar metabolic characteristics, in the search for a sub-optimal scenario for validity.
Physical activity during leisure time (estimated as MET-h week(-1)) derived from the self-administered questionnaire moderately correlated with kcal day(-1) assessed through the accelerometer (Spearman's rho = 0.507, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.232, 0.707). The Spearman correlation between the ratio of sedentary lifestyle to physical activity obtained through the questionnaire and the direct estimation (RT3) was -0.578 (95% CI -0.754, -0.325). The kappa index was 0.25 (P = 0.002) when assessing the cross-classification into quintiles and 0.41 for the dichotomous estimation of a sedentary lifestyle. Only 2.5% of participants were misclassified by the questionnaire more than two quintiles apart from the estimates of the RT3.
The moderate values obtained for correlation in a sub-optimal scenario for validity and the low percentage of extreme misclassification suggest the validity of the questionnaire to assess physical activity in Spanish-speaking women aged 20-50 years.
本分析的目的是,以三轴加速度计(RT3三轴研究追踪器)作为参考,检验通过改编自美国问卷(护士健康研究和卫生专业人员随访研究)的西班牙语版体力活动自填问卷得出的能量消耗和久坐生活方式估计值的有效性。
验证研究,计算自填问卷收集的体力活动水平和久坐生活方式与三轴加速度计测量值之间的非参数相关系数。还计算了错误分类百分比和kappa系数。
研究人群包括40名肥胖女性样本,她们是SUN(纳瓦拉大学跟踪研究)项目的参与者(一项针对西班牙大学校友的前瞻性队列研究)。选择她们是因为其特殊的代谢特征,以寻找一个有效性欠佳的次优情况。
自填问卷得出的休闲时间体力活动(以代谢当量-小时/周估算)与通过加速度计评估的千卡/天呈中度相关(斯皮尔曼相关系数ρ=0.507,95%置信区间(CI)0.232,0.707)。通过问卷得出的久坐生活方式与体力活动的比率和直接估算值(RT3)之间的斯皮尔曼相关系数为-0.578(95%CI -0.754,-0.325)。在评估分为五分位数的交叉分类时,kappa指数为0.25(P=0.002),对于久坐生活方式的二分法估计,kappa指数为0.41。与RT3的估计值相比,只有2.5%的参与者被问卷错误分类超过两个五分位数。
在有效性欠佳的次优情况下得出的中度相关值以及极低的极端错误分类百分比表明,该问卷对于评估20至50岁西班牙语女性的体力活动具有有效性。