Catov Janet M, Newman Anne B, Kelsey Sheryl F, Roberts James M, Sutton-Tyrrell Kim C, Garcia Melissa, Ayonayon Hilsa N, Tylavsky Francis, Ness Roberta B
Department of Epidemiology, University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Ann Epidemiol. 2006 Jun;16(6):429-31. doi: 10.1016/j.annepidem.2005.09.004. Epub 2005 Nov 8.
We assessed the accuracy and reliability of maternal recall of infant birth weight 35 to 70 years after delivery.
A total of 120 well functioning women (mean age 80 years; 45% Black) reported the birth weight for each live birth and then provided documentation of birth weights (n = 22) or reported birth weights a second time (n = 98).
Agreement between recalled and documented birth weights was high for first births (ICC = 0.96) but moderate for subsequent births (ICC = 0.59). Maternal recall was highly reliable for first births (r = 0.95) and subsequent births (r = 0.87), and reliability remained high when considered separately by race, education, income, and age.
Women report accurate and reliable infant birth-weight data an average of 57 years after delivery, and recall is particularly precise for first births.
我们评估了产后35至70年母亲回忆婴儿出生体重的准确性和可靠性。
共有120名功能良好的女性(平均年龄80岁;45%为黑人)报告了每次活产的出生体重,然后提供了出生体重的文件记录(n = 22)或再次报告出生体重(n = 98)。
首次分娩时回忆的出生体重与记录的出生体重之间的一致性较高(组内相关系数ICC = 0.96),但后续分娩时一致性中等(ICC = 0.59)。母亲对首次分娩的回忆高度可靠(r = 0.95),对后续分娩的回忆也可靠(r = 0.87),按种族、教育程度、收入和年龄分别考虑时,可靠性仍然很高。
女性在分娩后平均57年报告的婴儿出生体重数据准确可靠,且对首次分娩的回忆尤为精确。