Li Chung-Yi, Wei Jung-Nan, Lu Tsung-Hsueh, Chuang Lee-Ming, Sung Fung-Chang
Department of Public Health, Fu-Jen Catholic University College of Medicine, Taipei Hsien, Taiwan.
J Clin Epidemiol. 2006 Dec;59(12):1319-25. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2006.02.018. Epub 2006 Aug 24.
We validated infant birth weight by interview with mothers.
Infant birth weights obtained from maternal interview were compared with the data documented in birth certificates. Study subjects were mothers of 1,432 schoolchildren who participated in a diabetes mass screening program in 1992-1997, Taiwan. Data of infant birth weight obtained from telephone interview with mothers were compared with those from birth certificates to evaluate the accuracy of maternal report in eight categorized groups: <2,000, 2,000-2,499, 2,500-2,999, 3,000-3,499, 3,500-3,999, 4,000-4,499, 4,500-4,999, and >or=5,000 g.
The exact agreement was as low as 15.9% but increased substantially to 67.7% if maternal reports of weight one category higher than birth registry weight were considered to be indicative of agreement. Lower orders of birth weight were significantly associated with reports of higher category. But teen mothers and/or low-income mothers were associated with lower risks of overreport.
Our data suggested that birth weight-associated studies in Taiwan should "round number" to an upper category rather than a lower category to avoid serious misclassification in birth weight.
我们通过与母亲访谈来验证婴儿出生体重。
将通过母亲访谈获得的婴儿出生体重与出生证明上记录的数据进行比较。研究对象是1992 - 1997年在台湾参加糖尿病大规模筛查项目的1432名学童的母亲。将通过电话访谈母亲获得的婴儿出生体重数据与出生证明上的数据进行比较,以评估母亲报告在八个分类组中的准确性:<2000、2000 - 2499、2500 - 2999、3000 - 3499、3500 - 3999、4000 - 4499、4500 - 4999以及≥5000克。
完全一致率低至15.9%,但如果将母亲报告的比出生登记体重高一个类别的体重视为一致,则该比率大幅提高至67.7%。较低的出生体重等级与较高类别报告显著相关。但青少年母亲和/或低收入母亲报告过高的风险较低。
我们的数据表明,台湾地区与出生体重相关的研究应将体重“取整”到较高类别而非较低类别,以避免出生体重的严重错误分类。