Maguire M P
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 1977 Mar 21;277(955):245-58. doi: 10.1098/rstb.1977.0015.
Commonly accepted precepts are challenged: (1) that homologous chromosome pairing is normally mediated by nuclear envelope attachment sites; (2) that crossover site establishment awaits synaptic completion; and (3) that it is the function of the synaptonemal complex to hold homologues in register so that equal crossing over can occur, and perhaps to provide machinery for the crossover process. Although these views may eventually be shown to be true, it is felt that currently available evidence does not warrant their full acceptance, and that alternatives should be considered. As examples of alternatives the following ideas, with some supporting evidence, are suggested: (1) homologous chromosome pairing (in non-haplont organisms) may be accomplished by chance meeting of homologue segments (followed by establishment of invisible, elastic connectors) at congression for a mitotic metaphase (in many cases perhaps the premeiotic mitosis); (2) crossover sites may be established before, during, or immediately following initiation of synapsis; and (3) the synaptonemal complex may somehow function in the crossover process at the inception of its formation, but its complete deployment throughout each normal bivalent may serve some other role, such as mediation of the binding of sister chromatids apparently required for chiasma maintenance until anaphase I.
(1)同源染色体配对通常由核膜附着位点介导;(2)交叉位点的建立等待联会完成;(3)联会复合体的功能是使同源染色体对齐,以便能发生均等交换,或许还为交换过程提供机制。尽管这些观点最终可能被证明是正确的,但目前认为现有证据并不足以使其被完全接受,应该考虑其他可能性。作为其他可能性的例子,现提出以下一些有一定支持证据的观点:(1)同源染色体配对(在非单倍体生物中)可能是通过同源片段在有丝分裂中期(在许多情况下可能是减数分裂前的有丝分裂)的赤道板处偶然相遇(随后形成不可见的弹性连接物)来实现;(2)交叉位点可能在联会开始之前、期间或之后立即建立;(3)联会复合体可能在其形成之初以某种方式在交换过程中发挥作用,但其在每个正常二价体中的完全展开可能起到其他作用,比如介导姐妹染色单体的结合,这显然是直到减数第一次分裂后期交叉点维持所必需的。