Vandenplas O, Ghezzo H, Munoz X, Moscato G, Perfetti L, Lemière C, Labrecque M, L'Archevêque J, Malo J-L
Service de Pneumologie, Cliniques universitaires de Mont-Godinne, Université Catholique de Louvain, Yvoir, Belgium.
Eur Respir J. 2005 Dec;26(6):1056-63. doi: 10.1183/09031936.05.00024705.
The present study assessed the usefulness of key items obtained from a clinical "open" questionnaire prospectively administered to 212 subjects, referred to four tertiary-care hospitals for predicting the diagnosis of occupational asthma (OA). Of these subjects, 72 (34%) were diagnosed as OA (53% with OA due to high-molecular-weight agents) according to results of specific inhalation challenges, and 90 (42%) as non-OA. Wheezing at work occurred in 88% of subjects with OA and was the most specific symptom (85%). Nasal and eye symptoms were commonly associated symptoms. Wheezing, nasal and ocular itching at work were positively, and loss of voice negatively associated with the presence of OA in the case of high-, but not low molecular-weight agents. A prediction model based on responses to nasal itching, daily symptoms over the week at work, nasal secretions, absence of loss of voice, wheezing, and sputum, correctly predicted 156 out of 212 (74%) subjects according to the presence or absence of OA by final diagnosis. In conclusion, key items, i.e. wheezing, nasal and ocular itching and loss of voice, are satisfactorily associated with the presence of occupational asthma in subjects exposed to high-molecular-weight agents. Therefore, these should be addressed with high priority by physicians. However, no questionnaire-derived item is helpful in subjects exposed to low-molecular-weight agents.
本研究评估了从一份临床“开放式”问卷中获取的关键项目的效用,该问卷前瞻性地施用于212名受试者,这些受试者被转诊至四家三级医疗机构以预测职业性哮喘(OA)的诊断。在这些受试者中,根据特异性吸入激发试验结果,72名(34%)被诊断为OA(53%的OA由高分子量物质引起),90名(42%)被诊断为非OA。88%的OA受试者工作时出现喘息,这是最具特异性的症状(85%)。鼻和眼症状是常见的伴随症状。对于高分子量物质而非低分子量物质,工作时的喘息、鼻和眼瘙痒与OA的存在呈正相关,而声音嘶哑与OA的存在呈负相关。基于对鼻瘙痒、一周工作期间的日常症状、鼻分泌物、无声音嘶哑、喘息和痰液的回答所建立的预测模型,根据最终诊断的OA存在与否,正确预测了212名受试者中的156名(74%)。总之,关键项目,即喘息、鼻和眼瘙痒以及声音嘶哑,与接触高分子量物质的受试者中职业性哮喘的存在有令人满意的相关性。因此,医生应高度重视这些项目。然而,对于接触低分子量物质的受试者,问卷中的任何项目都没有帮助。