Lyman J T, Phillips M H, Frankel K A, Levy R P, Fabrikant J I
Division of Research Medicine and Radiation Biophysics, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley.
Neurosurg Clin N Am. 1992 Jan;3(1):1-8.
For the particles and energies considered suitable for radiosurgery, with increasing particle charge, the Bragg peak height reaches a maximum with helium and then decreases, the Bragg peak width narrows, the distal fall-off steepens, and the exit dose increases (Table 1). The helium-ion beam is superior to a proton beam because of the higher peak-plateau ratio, more rapid dose fall-off, and smaller beam deflection, and it suffers only in the modest exit dose. Comparison of the therapeutically useful parameters of these beams is complicated by the change in beam quality (LET) with depth. Considerations of RBE values, which change with the ion species and with depth of penetration, may alter the relative rankings based on one or more of these beam characterization values. For all these beams, the RBE increases with increasing LET. The effect for protons is small and occurs just at the end of range of the particles. Effective isodose distributions based on modeled beams have been reported for helium, carbon, and neon ions. These distributions include the effects of a varying RBE with changes in the beam quality (as measured by a dose-weighted LET) and the change in dose fraction size with depth (the dose per fraction is a function of the depth of penetration). These calculations suggest that the optimal charged-particle beam for radiosurgery might be carbon. Heavy charged-particle beams can produce dose distributions superior to those obtainable with photon or electron beams. In clinical trials, these dose distributions have proved to be useful for the treatment of human diseases, including neoplasia and life-threatening intracranial disorders.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对于被认为适用于放射外科的粒子和能量而言,随着粒子电荷增加,布拉格峰高度在氦离子时达到最大值,然后下降,布拉格峰宽度变窄,远端剂量下降变陡,且出射剂量增加(表1)。氦离子束优于质子束,因为其峰坪比更高、剂量下降更快且束流偏折更小,只是出射剂量略显高些。这些束流治疗相关有用参数的比较因束流质量(传能线密度)随深度的变化而变得复杂。考虑到相对生物效应值会随离子种类和穿透深度而变化,可能会改变基于这些束流特性值中一个或多个的相对排名。对于所有这些束流,相对生物效应随传能线密度增加而增大。质子的这种效应很小,且仅在粒子射程末端出现。已报道了基于模拟束流的有效等剂量分布,涉及氦、碳和氖离子。这些分布包括了随着束流质量变化(通过剂量加权传能线密度测量)时相对生物效应的变化以及剂量分数大小随深度的变化(每分数剂量是穿透深度的函数)。这些计算表明,放射外科的最佳带电粒子束可能是碳离子束。重带电粒子束能产生优于光子或电子束的剂量分布。在临床试验中,这些剂量分布已被证明对治疗人类疾病有用,包括肿瘤和危及生命的颅内疾病。(摘要截取自250词)