Aiello Erin J, Taplin Stephen, Reid Robert, Hobbs Maria, Seger Deborah, Kamel Hakim, Tufano Jim, Ballard-Barbash Rachel
Group Health Cooperative, Center for Health Studies, 1730 Minor Ave, Suite 1600, Seattle, WA 98101, USA.
J Clin Epidemiol. 2006 Jan;59(1):77-81. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2005.07.007. Epub 2005 Oct 13.
We evaluated patient acceptance of an electronic questionnaire to collect breast cancer risk-factor data in a mammography setting.
We developed an electronic questionnaire on a tablet computer incorporating prefilled answers and skip patterns. Using a randomized controlled study design, we tested the survey in a mammography clinic that administers a paper risk-factor questionnaire to every woman at her screening mammogram. We randomized 160 women to use the electronic survey (experimental group, n = 86) or paper survey (control group, n = 74). We evaluated patient acceptance and data completeness.
Overall, 70.4% of the experimental group women thought the survey was very easy to use, compared to 55.6% of women in the control group. Ninety percent of experimental group women preferred using the tablet, compared to the paper questionnaire. Preference for the tablet did not differ by age; however, women > or = 60 years did not find the tablet as easy to use as did women < 60 years. The proportion of missing data was significantly lower on the tablet compared to the paper questionnaire (4.6% vs. 6.2%, P = .04).
Electronic questionnaires are feasible to use in a mammography setting, can improve data quality, and are preferred by women regardless of age.
我们评估了在乳腺钼靶检查环境中患者对用于收集乳腺癌风险因素数据的电子问卷的接受程度。
我们在平板电脑上开发了一份包含预填答案和跳转模式的电子问卷。采用随机对照研究设计,在一家乳腺钼靶诊所对该调查问卷进行测试,该诊所会在每位女性进行乳腺钼靶筛查时向其发放纸质风险因素问卷。我们将160名女性随机分为使用电子调查问卷组(实验组,n = 86)或纸质调查问卷组(对照组,n = 74)。我们评估了患者的接受程度和数据完整性。
总体而言,实验组中70.4%的女性认为该调查问卷非常易于使用,而对照组中这一比例为55.6%。与纸质问卷相比,90%的实验组女性更喜欢使用平板电脑。对平板电脑的偏好不受年龄影响;然而,60岁及以上的女性并不像60岁以下的女性那样觉得平板电脑易于使用。与纸质问卷相比,平板电脑上缺失数据的比例显著更低(4.6%对6.2%,P = .04)。
电子问卷在乳腺钼靶检查环境中使用是可行的,能够提高数据质量,并且无论年龄大小都受到女性的青睐。