Schober Justine M, Kuhn Phyllis J, Kovacs Paul G, Earle James H, Byrne Peter M, Fries Ruth A
Hamot Medical Center, Erie, PA 16507, USA.
Arch Sex Behav. 2005 Dec;34(6):691-705. doi: 10.1007/s10508-005-7929-2.
Cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy was compared with cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy augmented by leuprolide acetate (LA) for suppression of pedophilic behavior. Five male pedophiles (M age, 50 years; range, 36-58) were administered LA by Depo injection for 12 months, followed by saline placebo for 12 months. Testosterone levels, sexual interest preference by visual reaction time (Abel Assessment), penile tumescence (Monarch Penile Plethysmography, PPG), as well as strong sexual urges toward children and masturbatory frequency involving thoughts of children (polygraph), were measured every 3 months. On LA, testosterone decreased to castrate levels. Penile tumescence was significantly suppressed compared with baseline, but sufficient response remained to detect pedophilic interest. Pedophilic interest was also detected by visual reaction times. When asked about having pedophilic urges and masturbating to thoughts of children, all subjects self-reported a decrease. Polygraph responses indicated subjects were not deceptive. On placebo, testosterone and physiologic arousal eventually rose to baseline. As noted by polygraph, at baseline and on placebo, subjects were deceptive regarding increased pedophilic urges and masturbatory frequency. Interest preference, as measured by Abel Assessment and Monarch PPG, was generally unchanged throughout the study. Cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy augmented with LA significantly reduced pedophilic fantasies, urges, and masturbation; however, pedophilic interest did not change during 1 year of therapy. Deceptive responses by polygraph suggested that self-report was unreliable. Follow-up utilizing objective measures is essential for monitoring efficacy of treatment in pedophilia. Our study supports the premise that suppression of pedophilic behavior is possible. LA may augment cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy and help break the sequence leading to a re-offense.
将认知行为心理治疗与醋酸亮丙瑞林(LA)增强的认知行为心理治疗进行比较,以抑制恋童癖行为。对5名男性恋童癖者(平均年龄50岁;范围36 - 58岁)进行为期12个月的长效注射用LA治疗,随后12个月给予生理盐水安慰剂。每3个月测量睾酮水平、通过视觉反应时间评估的性兴趣偏好(阿贝尔评估)、阴茎勃起(君主阴茎体积描记法,PPG),以及对儿童的强烈性冲动和涉及儿童想法的手淫频率(测谎仪)。使用LA时,睾酮降至去势水平。与基线相比,阴茎勃起明显受到抑制,但仍有足够的反应来检测恋童癖兴趣。通过视觉反应时间也检测到了恋童癖兴趣。当被问及是否有恋童癖冲动以及手淫时脑海中出现儿童想法时,所有受试者自我报告有所减少。测谎仪反应表明受试者没有欺骗行为。使用安慰剂时,睾酮和生理唤醒最终恢复到基线水平。如测谎仪所示,在基线和使用安慰剂时,受试者在恋童癖冲动增加和手淫频率方面存在欺骗行为。在整个研究过程中,通过阿贝尔评估和君主PPG测量的兴趣偏好总体上没有变化。LA增强的认知行为心理治疗显著减少了恋童癖幻想、冲动和手淫;然而,在1年的治疗期间恋童癖兴趣没有改变。测谎仪的欺骗性反应表明自我报告不可靠。利用客观测量进行随访对于监测恋童癖治疗效果至关重要。我们的研究支持抑制恋童癖行为是可能的这一前提。LA可能增强认知行为心理治疗,并有助于打破导致再次犯罪的行为序列。