Zanchin Giorgio, Dainese Filippo, Mainardi Federico, Mampreso Edoardo, Perin Chiara, Maggioni Ferdinando
Headache Centre, Department of Neurosciences, University of Padua, Padua, Italy.
J Headache Pain. 2005 Sep;6(4):213-5. doi: 10.1007/s10194-005-0188-8.
This study evaluates osmophobia (defined as an unpleasant perception, during a headache attack, of odours that are non-aversive or even pleasurable outside the attacks) in connection with the diagnosis of primary headaches. We recruited 775 patients from our Headache Centre (566 females, 209 males; age 38+/-12 years), of whom 477 were migraineurs without aura (MO), 92 with aura (MA), 135 had episodic tension-type headache (ETTH), 44 episodic cluster headache (ECH), 2 chronic paroxysmal hemicrania (CPH) and 25 other primary headaches (OPHs: 12 primary stabbing headaches, 2 primary cough headaches, 3 primary exertional headaches, 2 primary headaches associated with sexual activity, 3 hypnic headaches, 2 primary thunderclap headaches and 1 hemicrania continua). Among them, 43% with MO (205/477), 39% with MA (36/92), and 7% with CH (3/44) reported osmophobia during the attacks; none of the 135 ETTH and 25 OPH patients suffered this symptom. We conclude that osmophobia is a very specific marker to discriminate adequately between migraine (MO and MA) and ETTH; moreover, from this limited series it seems to be a good discriminant also for OPHs, and for CH patients not sharing neurovegetative symptoms with migraine. Therefore, osmophobia should be considered a good candidate as a new criterion for the diagnosis of migraine.
本研究评估恐嗅症(定义为在头痛发作期间,对在发作之外并无厌恶甚至令人愉悦的气味产生不愉快的感觉)与原发性头痛诊断之间的关系。我们从头痛中心招募了775名患者(566名女性,209名男性;年龄38±12岁),其中477名是无先兆偏头痛患者(MO),92名有先兆偏头痛患者(MA),135名有发作性紧张型头痛(ETTH),44名发作性丛集性头痛(ECH),2名慢性阵发性半侧头痛(CPH)以及25名其他原发性头痛患者(OPH:12名原发性刺痛性头痛,2名原发性咳嗽性头痛,3名原发性劳力性头痛,2名与性活动相关的原发性头痛,3名睡眠性头痛,2名原发性霹雳样头痛以及1名持续性半侧头痛)。其中,43%的MO患者(205/477)、39%的MA患者(36/92)以及7%的CH患者(3/44)在发作期间报告有恐嗅症;135名ETTH患者和25名OPH患者均未出现此症状。我们得出结论,恐嗅症是在偏头痛(MO和MA)与ETTH之间进行充分鉴别的非常特异的标志物;此外,从这个有限的系列研究来看,它似乎也是OPH以及不伴有偏头痛自主神经症状的CH患者的良好鉴别指标。因此,恐嗅症应被视为偏头痛诊断新标准的一个良好候选指标。