Kinder B, Brubaker R, Ingram R, Reading E
Dept. of Psychology, University of South Florida, Tampa 33620, USA.
J Pers Assess. 1982 Apr;46(2):131-8. doi: 10.1207/s15327752jpa4602_4.
The Beck and Exner systems of assigning Rorschach form quality were compared, There are some inherent differences in the form quality tables of these two Rorschach systematizers. The Beck system is more extensive and seems slightly biased toward-or "poor" form quality in comparison to the Exner system. When the Rorschach records of psychiatric patients were scored for form quality, the Beck system yielded a significantly lower Extended F+% than the Exner system. This effect is probably related to the inherent differences in the respective form quality tables which resulted from the different procedures used in deriving these listings of form quality.
对用于罗夏墨迹测验图形质量赋值的贝克系统和埃克斯纳系统进行了比较。这两位罗夏墨迹测验系统编制者的图形质量表存在一些内在差异。与埃克斯纳系统相比，贝克系统更为宽泛，似乎对“差”的图形质量略有偏向。当对精神病患者的罗夏墨迹测验记录进行图形质量评分时，贝克系统得出的扩展F+%显著低于埃克斯纳系统。这种效应可能与各自图形质量表中的内在差异有关，这些差异源于得出这些图形质量列表所采用的不同程序。
