Handler Marcie W, DuPaul George J
The May Institute, Norwood, Massachusetts, USA.
J Atten Disord. 2005 Nov;9(2):402-12. doi: 10.1177/1087054705278762.
Child psychologists are frequently involved in the assessment of ADHD symptoms among school-aged youth. There is limited information regarding the extent to which psychologists adhere to recommended assessment practices and whether differences exist in assessment strategies among psychologists from different specialty areas (clinical, counseling, and school) and/or who practice in different settings (university, school, or outpatient clinic). A 3 (specialty area) x 3 (employment setting) between-groups design is used wherein 230 child psychologists completed surveys regarding diagnostic practice. Psychologists differ in adherence with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed., text revision) diagnostic criteria, use of clinical interviews, and type of behavior observation. Only 15% of psychologists report using multiple methods consistent with recommended standards of best practice. Differences between groups of psychologists indicate that the diagnosis of ADHD in children is influenced by the type of psychologist conducting the evaluation and the setting in which the evaluation is conducted.
儿童心理学家经常参与对学龄青少年多动症症状的评估。关于心理学家在何种程度上遵循推荐的评估方法,以及来自不同专业领域(临床、咨询和学校)和/或在不同环境(大学、学校或门诊诊所)执业的心理学家在评估策略上是否存在差异,相关信息有限。采用了一种3(专业领域)×3(工作环境)的组间设计,其中230名儿童心理学家完成了关于诊断实践的调查。心理学家在遵循《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(第4版,修订版)诊断标准、使用临床访谈以及行为观察类型方面存在差异。只有15%的心理学家报告称使用了符合最佳实践推荐标准的多种方法。心理学家群体之间的差异表明,儿童多动症的诊断受到进行评估的心理学家类型以及评估进行的环境的影响。