Department of Psychiatry, University of California , San Francisco.
Department of Psychology, University of California , Berkeley.
J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 2020 Nov-Dec;49(6):854-867. doi: 10.1080/15374416.2019.1644647. Epub 2019 Aug 21.
Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder-predominantly inattentive presentation (ADHD-I) and specific learning disorder (SLD) are commonly co-occurring conditions. Despite the considerable diagnostic overlap, the effect of SLD comorbidity on outcomes of behavioral interventions for ADHD-I remains critically understudied. The current study examines the effect of reading or math SLD comorbidity in 35 children with comorbid ADHD-I+SLD and 39 children with ADHD-I only following a behavioral treatment integrated across home and school (Child Life and Attention Skills [CLAS]). Pre- and posttreatment outcome measures included teacher-rated inattention, organizational deficits, and study skills and parent-rated inattention, organizational deficits, and homework problems. A similar pattern emerged across all teacher-rated measures: Children with ADHD-I and comorbid ADHD-I+SLD did not differ significantly at baseline, but between-group differences were evident following the CLAS intervention. Specifically, children with ADHD-I and comorbid ADHD-I+SLD improved on teacher-rated measures following the CLAS intervention, but children with ADHD-I only experienced greater improvement relative to those with a comorbid SLD. No significant interactions were observed on parent-rated measures-all children improved following the CLAS intervention on parent-rated measures, regardless of SLD status. The current results reveal that children with ADHD-I+SLD comorbidity benefit significantly from multimodal behavioral interventions, although improvements in the school setting are attenuated significantly. A treatment-resistant fraction of inattention was identified only in the SLD group, implying that this fraction is related to SLD and becomes apparent only when behavioral intervention for ADHD is administered.
注意力缺陷/多动障碍-主要注意力不集中型(ADHD-I)和特定学习障碍(SLD)是常见的共病情况。尽管存在相当大的诊断重叠,但 SLD 共病对 ADHD-I 行为干预结果的影响仍严重研究不足。本研究在 35 名共患 ADHD-I+SLD 的儿童和 39 名仅患有 ADHD-I 的儿童中,检查了阅读或数学 SLD 共病对行为治疗(儿童生活和注意技能[CLAS])的影响。治疗前后的结果评估包括教师评定的注意力不集中、组织缺陷和学习技能以及父母评定的注意力不集中、组织缺陷和家庭作业问题。所有教师评定测量都出现了类似的模式:ADHD-I 儿童和共患 ADHD-I+SLD 儿童在基线时没有显著差异,但在 CLAS 干预后出现了组间差异。具体而言,ADHD-I 儿童和共患 ADHD-I+SLD 儿童在 CLAS 干预后在教师评定的测量中得到改善,但 ADHD-I 儿童的改善程度相对那些患有共患 SLD 的儿童更大。在父母评定的测量中没有观察到显著的交互作用——所有儿童在 CLAS 干预后都在父母评定的测量中得到改善,无论 SLD 状况如何。目前的结果表明,ADHD-I+SLD 共病儿童从多模式行为干预中显著获益,尽管在学校环境中的改善明显减弱。仅在 SLD 组中发现了注意力不集中的治疗抵抗部分,这意味着这部分与 SLD 有关,并且仅在对 ADHD 进行行为干预时才会显现出来。