Foley Kristie Long, George Geeta, Crandall Sonia J, Walker Kathy H, Marion Gail S, Spangler John G
Department of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University, USA.
Fam Med. 2006 Jan;38(1):28-37.
A comprehensive training program to develop tobacco-specific standardized patient instructors (SPIs) was implemented and evaluated at Wake Forest University.
Descriptive statistics were used to assess SPIs' experience with the training program and medical students' perceptions of the SPI-student interaction. Two standardized scales, used to assess student performance on counseling (Tobacco Intervention Risk Factor Interview Scale [TIRFIS]) and cultural competency (Tobacco Beliefs Management Scale-Tobacco Cultural Concerns Scale [TBMS-TCCS]), were tested for internal and interrater reliability and sensitivity to varied student performance. Costs of the program were measured.
SPIs highly rated the content, organization, and presenters of the training program. Medical students positively evaluated their experience with the SPIs. The TIRFIS and TBMS-TCCS subscales demonstrated good internal reliability, and inconsistencies in ratings by different SPIs were minimal. In addition, a range of scores on both measures attest to the sensitivity of the instruments to assess variations in student performance. Significant start-up costs are associated with developing this training program, although costs decline when SPIs are retained long term.
The SPI training program was effective in developing a cohort of knowledgeable and reliable SPIs to train medical students in ways to improve their tobacco intervention counseling skills. Retaining SPIs long term should be a primary goal of implementing a cost-effective, successful training program.
在维克森林大学实施并评估了一项旨在培养烟草特定标准化病人教员(SPIs)的综合培训项目。
使用描述性统计来评估标准化病人教员对培训项目的体验以及医学生对标准化病人教员与学生互动的看法。对用于评估学生咨询表现的两个标准化量表(烟草干预风险因素访谈量表 [TIRFIS])和文化能力(烟草信念管理量表 - 烟草文化关注量表 [TBMS - TCCS])进行了内部信度、评分者间信度以及对不同学生表现的敏感性测试。对该项目的成本进行了测算。
标准化病人教员对培训项目的内容、组织和授课人员给予了高度评价。医学生对他们与标准化病人教员的经历给予了积极评价。TIRFIS 和 TBMS - TCCS 子量表显示出良好的内部信度,不同标准化病人教员的评分不一致性最小。此外,这两项测量的一系列分数证明了这些工具在评估学生表现差异方面的敏感性。开发这个培训项目涉及大量启动成本,不过如果长期保留标准化病人教员,成本会下降。
标准化病人教员培训项目有效地培养了一批知识渊博且可靠的标准化病人教员,以培训医学生提高他们的烟草干预咨询技能。长期保留标准化病人教员应该是实施一个具有成本效益且成功的培训项目的首要目标。