Shimizu Katsuhiko, Ikeda Norihiko, Tsuboi Masahiro, Hirano Takashi, Kato Harubumi
First Department of Surgery, Tokyo Medical University, Nishishinjyuku, Shinjyuku-ku, Japan.
Lung Cancer. 2006 Feb;51(2):173-9. doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2005.10.019. Epub 2005 Dec 27.
The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate the value of preoperative percutaneous CT-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy (CTNB) for peripheral lung cancers less than 2 cm in size, especially in cases showing of ground-glass opacities (GGO). From 1999 to 2002, 151 small lung cancers were resected in Tokyo Medical University Hospital. Among them, 96 patients (63.6%) in whom the lesions were located in the outer half of the lung field underwent CTNB in order to obtain a preoperative diagnosis. The factors influencing the diagnostic yield were analyzed. The overall diagnostic yield of CTNB was 64.6%: 48.5% for lesions smaller than 10 mm, 62.5% for those 11-15 mm, and 83.9% for those 16-20 mm, respectively. The diagnostic yield in GGO-dominant lesions (GGO ratio < 50%) and solid-dominant lesions (GGO ratio < 50%) were 51.2% and 75.6% (p = 0.018). In the GGO-dominant group, the diagnostic yields were 35.2% for lesions smaller than 10 mm, 50.0% for those 11-15 mm, and 80.0% for those 16-20 mm. In the solid-dominant group, diagnostic yield was 62.5% for cases smaller than 10 mm, 75% for 11-15 mm and 85.7% for 16-20 mm, respectively. Satisfactory diagnostic yield (>80%) was obtained by CTNB in cases larger than 15 mm. CTNB is a useful diagnostic modality for peripheral small lung cancers; however, for GGO-dominant lesions, the preoperative diagnostic yield is not significantly better than for solid-dominant lesions.
本回顾性研究的目的是评估术前经皮CT引导下细针穿刺活检(CTNB)对直径小于2 cm的周围型肺癌的价值,尤其是对表现为磨玻璃影(GGO)的病例。1999年至2002年,东京医科大学医院共切除151例小肺癌。其中,96例(63.6%)病变位于肺野外半侧的患者接受了CTNB以获得术前诊断。分析了影响诊断率的因素。CTNB的总体诊断率为64.6%:直径小于10 mm的病变诊断率为48.5%,11 - 15 mm的病变诊断率为62.5%,16 - 20 mm的病变诊断率为83.9%。以GGO为主的病变(GGO比例<50%)和实性为主的病变(GGO比例<50%)的诊断率分别为51.2%和75.6%(p = 0.018)。在以GGO为主的组中,直径小于10 mm的病变诊断率为35.2%,11 - 15 mm的病变诊断率为50.0%,16 - 20 mm的病变诊断率为80.0%。在实性为主的组中,直径小于10 mm的病例诊断率为62.5%,11 - 15 mm的病例诊断率为75%,16 - 20 mm的病例诊断率为85.7%。直径大于15 mm的病例通过CTNB获得了满意的诊断率(>80%)。CTNB是诊断周围型小肺癌的一种有用的诊断方法;然而,对于以GGO为主的病变,术前诊断率并不比实性为主的病变显著更好。