Andrews Gavin J, Brodie David A, Andrews Justin P, Hillan Edith, Gail Thomas B, Wong Josephine, Rixon Lorna
Faculty of Nursing, University of Toronto, 50 St. George Street, Toronto, Ont., Canada M5S3H4.
Int J Nurs Stud. 2006 Sep;43(7):861-74. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2005.11.008. Epub 2005 Dec 27.
Research evidence suggests that clinical placements are important to both the perceptions and outcomes of nurse education. Nevertheless, despite this knowledge, research also indicates that many students receive negative experiences whilst attending these 'remote' settings, sometimes resulting in missed opportunities for learning and negative impressions of potential places of employment.
In this context, this study investigates the experiences and perceptions of students relating to their clinical placements and, in particular, their views on professional structuring. Specifically it addresses the roles of, and communications between, the key academics, clinical professionals and institutions responsible for their organization.
Focus group discussions with students (n=7) and an interview survey of ex-students (n=30) each from two British universities in Southeast England.
The research highlights the diverse experiences that student receive on clinical placements, as well as their own suggestions for improvements. Student informed models of worst, minimum, current and best practice are then presented, as well as a cross-setting evaluation feedback model. These highlight responsibilities and communications across health professionals and educational sites. The models include an emphasis on the roles of ward managers, mentors, link tutors and more generally on shared but clearly delineated institutional responsibility for quality assurance mechanisms. They offer the opportunity to improve educational practice in clinically-based education and concurrently to improve student experiences and outcomes.
Clinical placements are designed to provide practical learning through a 'slice of practice life'. However, it is necessary to maximize this learning experience. Placements certainly need not be the worst slice.
研究证据表明,临床实习对护士教育的认知和成果都很重要。然而,尽管有这些认识,但研究也表明,许多学生在参加这些“远程”实习时会有负面经历,有时会导致学习机会的错失以及对潜在就业场所的负面印象。
在此背景下,本研究调查了学生与临床实习相关的经历和看法,特别是他们对专业结构的看法。具体而言,它探讨了负责组织实习的关键学者、临床专业人员和机构的作用以及他们之间的沟通。
对来自英格兰东南部两所英国大学的学生(n = 7)进行焦点小组讨论,并对往届学生(n = 30)进行访谈调查。
该研究突出了学生在临床实习中获得的多样经历,以及他们自己提出的改进建议。随后展示了学生所知晓的最差、最低、当前和最佳实践模式,以及一个跨环境评估反馈模式。这些突出了卫生专业人员和教育场所之间的责任与沟通。这些模式强调了病房管理人员、导师、联络教师的作用,更普遍地强调了对质量保证机制的共同但明确界定的机构责任。它们提供了改善基于临床的教育中的教育实践的机会,同时改善学生的经历和成果。
临床实习旨在通过“一段实践生活”提供实践学习。然而,有必要将这种学习体验最大化。实习肯定不必是最糟糕的一段经历。